
Attractive, Acceptable and Affordable deep Renovation by a consumers orientated and performance evidence based approach
TripleA-reno developed the Energy Transition Board Game, an original tabletop simulation designed to support decisions about sustainable home renovation. Players select improvement measures under different scenarios and balance energy savings, comfort, maintenance and economic considerations. The Horizon 2020 game was tested during development, demonstrated in professional workshops and subsequently reused in community engagement activities.
1. Project Overview
- Funding programme
- Horizon 2020 – Secure, Clean and Efficient Energy
- Project reference
- 784972
- Period
- 2018–2021
- Coordinating organisation
- Huygen Installatie Adviseurs (Netherlands)
- Participating countries
- Netherlands, Belgium, Germany, Italy, Slovenia, Spain, Portugal, Hungary
- Official project website
- Visit official website
2. Learning Objectives
TripleA-reno (Attractive, Acceptable and Affordable deep Renovation by a consumers orientated and performance evidence based approach) aimed to make deep energy renovation more understandable, attractive and acceptable for residents, property owners, social housing providers and building professionals.
The project sought to overcome barriers to residential renovation by providing user-centred information, decision-support tools and practical opportunities to explore the benefits and challenges of improving building energy performance.
Within its wider programme, TripleA-reno developed the Energy Transition Board Game, also known as EnergieTransitieSpel, to support learning and discussion about sustainable home renovation through a physical tabletop experience.
Specific learning objectives
- Energy renovation awareness: Understand the purpose and potential benefits of improving the energy performance of existing homes.
- Energy literacy: Become familiar with technologies and measures used to reduce household energy demand.
- Renovation options: Recognise different possibilities for improving the building envelope, heating systems and other building components.
- Energy savings: Consider how different renovation measures may contribute to lower energy consumption.
- Economic awareness: Examine the relationship between renovation investments, operating costs and potential long-term savings.
- Indoor comfort: Understand how renovation decisions can influence thermal comfort and indoor environmental quality.
- Maintenance: Consider maintenance requirements when selecting renovation measures.
- Technical compatibility: Recognise that different improvements and building systems must be considered as part of an integrated renovation strategy.
- Resident preferences: Identify the importance of the needs, expectations and priorities of the people who occupy a home.
- Scenario-based decision-making: Compare possible combinations of renovation measures under different constraints and objectives.
- Trade-off analysis: Understand that a solution performing well in one dimension may present disadvantages in another.
- Balanced sustainability decisions: Consider energy performance together with economic feasibility and occupant comfort.
- Critical reasoning: Evaluate the suitability of different measures rather than assuming that one technological solution is appropriate in all circumstances.
- Communication: Encourage discussion between residents, technical advisers and other stakeholders involved in renovation.
- Collaborative problem-solving: Use scenarios and game components to develop and compare potential renovation strategies.
- Consumer empowerment: Help non-specialist participants understand choices that may otherwise depend entirely on technical professionals.
- Inclusive participation: Offer an offline learning format for participants who are less comfortable using digital technologies.
- Professional training: Support introductory education for students, building professionals and advisers working on residential energy efficiency.
- Community engagement: Encourage informed discussion about building renovation in housing associations, municipalities and local communities.
Examples of educational scenarios
Documented workshops used scenarios such as:
- Low maintenance costs: Select renovation measures while prioritising reduced maintenance requirements.
- Zero-Energy Building: Explore combinations of improvements intended to achieve very low or net-zero operational energy demand.
These scenarios demonstrate how the game can be used to compare renovation strategies according to different priorities.
Relationship with the wider project
The board game complements the project’s digital Open Gamified Platform and energy and comfort labelling tools.
Its educational role is to make complex renovation decisions accessible through physical interaction and discussion.
These objectives describe the intended educational contribution of the game. Independently measured improvements in knowledge, decision-making skills or actual renovation behaviour have not been established.
3. Target Groups
4. Board Games Used or Developed
TripleA-reno developed an original physical board game called Energy Transition Board Game, also known as EnergieTransitieSpel in Dutch.
The game was created within the Horizon 2020 TripleA-reno consortium with contributions from ISSO and DWA, supported by the European Union and Wij Techniek.
It was designed to help residents, students, building professionals and other stakeholders explore the opportunities and constraints associated with sustainable residential renovation.
1. Energy Transition Board Game / EnergieTransitieSpel
Participants are challenged to renovate an existing home under the conditions established by a scenario.
They use different renovation measures and chance cards on a physical game board, considering how their choices affect energy savings, comfort, installation, maintenance and economic performance.
Documented game characteristics
- Game type: Custom-designed educational board game.
- Format: Physical tabletop game with a board, cards, die, scoring sheet and rules.
- Educational theme: Residential energy renovation and sustainable building improvements.
- Primary audience: Building professionals, construction and technical students, homeowners, residents and housing organisations.
- Gameplay organisation: Can be played individually or in groups.
- Player count: An exact recommended numerical range has not been verified.
- Playing time: Not independently verified.
- Primary challenge: Select an appropriate combination of measures for a home within the conditions of a scenario.
- Scoring: A score sheet records performance, with the educational workshop documentation identifying additional points for balancing sustainability and cost.
- Development period: During the 2018–2021 TripleA-reno project.
Verified physical components
- One game board.
- 36 Renovation Measure Cards.
- 11 Scenario Cards.
- 9 Chance Cards.
- One score sheet.
- One die.
- One instruction manual.
Main game mechanisms
- Scenario selection: Players work within a scenario establishing the renovation objectives and constraints.
- Measure selection: Renovation Measure Cards represent possible improvements to an existing home.
- Combination of measures: Players select and combine improvements rather than considering each intervention in isolation.
- Physical placement: Cards are used on the game board to represent the renovation choices.
- Chance events: Chance Cards introduce additional conditions or uncertainty into the exercise.
- Multicriteria decisions: Players consider energy, economics, comfort, installation and maintenance.
- Resident-centred planning: The relevance of occupants’ preferences and needs forms part of the decision-making challenge.
- Scoring: A score sheet supports the assessment of renovation strategies.
- Trade-off optimisation: Additional points may reward balanced choices concerning sustainability and cost.
- Discussion: The game provides a basis for explaining, comparing and discussing different renovation strategies.
Documented scenarios
During a Housing Europe workshop on 15 February 2021, participants explored:
- Low Maintenance Costs.
- Zero-Energy Building.
These are two verified examples from the eleven Scenario Cards. The names and instructions of the other nine scenarios have not been independently established.
Educational use
The game is designed for use in:
- Higher education and technical training.
- Professional development for construction and building services practitioners.
- Municipal sustainability workshops.
- Social housing and housing association engagement activities.
- Meetings with property owners and residents.
- Early-stage renovation advice and consultation.
Accessibility and offline participation
The board game was intended to complement the TripleA-reno online platform, particularly where residents prefer direct personal interaction or face barriers to digital participation.
The project explicitly identified social housing residents, older adults and people with lower digital literacy as potential beneficiaries of the physical format.
This design intention does not, by itself, establish that the game was evaluated with each of these groups.
Resource availability
Build Up Skills Nederland maintains an active public description of the game, including its components and educational uses.
The page refers to commercial ordering through ISSO and gives a historical listed price of EUR 35.
However, the linked ISSO ordering page could not be opened successfully during the November 2026 review. Current stock, price and purchase availability therefore remain unverified.
No complete publicly downloadable print-and-play package has been identified.
Energy Transition Board Game – Official Build Up Skills Nederland Information
TripleA-reno – Instituto Valenciano de la Edificación
Game development and modification
The developers explicitly invited players and renovation experts to contribute improvements to the game.
Possible contributions include revising existing Measure Cards, creating new measures, adding reflection questions to Scenario Cards, designing new scenarios and proposing additional Chance Cards.
This collaborative improvement model may support adaptation to changing technologies, regulations and renovation practices.
However, permission for independent reproduction or redistribution should not be assumed. The public game description includes an all-rights-reserved notice.
Game approach
The appropriate classification is Custom-Designed Educational Games.
The Energy Transition Board Game was developed specifically through TripleA-reno rather than adapted from an existing commercial game.
5. BGBL Methodology
TripleA-reno adopted a user-centred Game-Based Learning approach to make residential energy renovation more understandable and engaging for professionals, property owners and residents.
The Energy Transition Board Game complements the project’s digital decision-support tools by providing a physical environment for exploring renovation scenarios, selecting improvement measures and discussing their consequences.
The methodology focuses on learning through decision-making, comparison and dialogue rather than exclusively through technical presentations or factual questions.
Pedagogical foundations
- Scenario-based learning: Participants consider renovation decisions within specific objectives and constraints.
- Experiential learning: The board game allows participants to explore simplified renovation processes through physical interaction with game materials.
- Decision-based learning: Players select measures and examine their suitability for different renovation challenges.
- Multicriteria analysis: Decisions involve several interrelated dimensions, including energy savings, comfort, economics, installation and maintenance.
- Problem-based learning: Players attempt to identify appropriate combinations of improvements for a particular housing scenario.
- Collaborative learning: Group activities create opportunities to exchange technical knowledge, experiences and perspectives.
- Consumer empowerment: The game introduces technical subjects through an accessible format that can support informed participation.
- Inclusive learning: Physical gameplay provides an alternative to digital-only decision-support systems.
- Reflective learning: Scenarios and renovation choices encourage discussion of the advantages and disadvantages of alternative interventions.
Development methodology
The game was developed within the TripleA-reno consortium, with contributions from ISSO and DWA.
The development process sought to connect technical knowledge about sustainable residential renovation with practical tools for communication and decision-making.
The documented development and dissemination activities included:
- Identification of barriers: The project investigated why residents, owners and housing organisations may find deep renovation difficult to understand or accept.
- Definition of educational objectives: The consortium identified the need to improve understanding of available measures and the consequences of renovation decisions.
- Game design: Renovation measures, scenarios and chance events were represented through physical game components.
- Prototype testing: Project partners examined the game’s usability and rules during development.
- Professional demonstration: The game was introduced during workshops involving housing organisations and building professionals.
- Feedback collection: Participants and project partners provided observations and suggestions for improving gameplay.
- Educational dissemination: The game was promoted for use in technical training, housing consultations and community workshops.
- Continued application: Following completion of TripleA-reno, the game was reused in activities of other European energy renovation projects.
Documented learning sequence
The publicly available information supports the following general structure:
- Introduction: Participants are introduced to the purpose of sustainable residential renovation and the game components.
- Scenario selection: A Scenario Card defines the conditions and priorities of the renovation challenge.
- Analysis: Players consider the objectives, including resident preferences, energy performance, comfort and economic factors.
- Measure selection: Participants choose renovation Measure Cards appropriate to the scenario.
- Combination of interventions: Selected measures are placed on the board to represent a possible renovation strategy.
- Chance events: Chance Cards introduce additional conditions affecting the decision-making exercise.
- Assessment: The game uses a score sheet to record performance against the scenario objectives.
- Discussion: Participants can compare alternative approaches and explain the reasoning behind their selections.
- Reflection: Educators or facilitators may discuss how the simulated decisions relate to actual renovation opportunities and constraints.
This description identifies the educational functions documented by the project and its partners. It is not a reconstruction of the complete official turn-by-turn rulebook, which has not been independently obtained.
Role of the facilitator
The game is intended for educational and professional contexts in which technical guidance may help participants understand the implications of renovation measures.
Facilitators may introduce the scenario, clarify unfamiliar terms, explain scoring criteria and encourage discussion of competing priorities.
During the February 2021 Housing Europe Home Show, a designated game leader explained the rules, coordinated the educational activity and supported discussion of two renovation scenarios.
In later community workshops, local renovation professionals provided advice and connected the game with actual renovation practices.
Debriefing and reflection
The developers explicitly invite users to improve the game by adding reflection questions to Scenario Cards.
This supports the interpretation of reflection as a recognised educational opportunity within the game’s design.
However, a separate standardised post-game debriefing handbook or formally evaluated reflection protocol has not been identified.
For educational use, discussion can examine why particular measures were chosen, what compromises were necessary and how the proposed strategy might perform under real building and financial conditions.
Methodological transferability
The game can support introductory education for construction students, professional development for renovation advisers and participation activities with residents.
Its scenario-based design offers opportunities for adapting educational challenges to different housing situations.
However, effective transfer between countries requires attention to differences in building characteristics, energy systems, regulations, renovation costs and available financial incentives.
6. Implementation & Evaluation
TripleA-reno was implemented between May 2018 and October 2021 as a Horizon 2020 project coordinated by Huygen Installatie Adviseurs in the Netherlands.
The consortium brought together research organisations, building professionals, housing associations, European professional networks and public institutions to promote consumer-centred deep energy renovation.
Its activities included residential demonstration cases, a digital gamified platform, performance labelling tools, stakeholder workshops and the development of an original educational board game.
Board-game development and participating organisations
- ISSO (Netherlands): Principal technical contributor associated with the development and subsequent dissemination of the Energy Transition Board Game.
- DWA (Netherlands): Game development collaboration.
- Huygen Installatie Adviseurs (Netherlands): Overall project coordination and development of consumer-centred renovation tools.
- Housing Europe (Belgium): Demonstration and promotion of the game within social, public and cooperative housing networks.
- Instituto Valenciano de la Edificación (Spain): Participation in prototype testing and dissemination.
- Institute for Innovation and Development of the University of Ljubljana (Slovenia): Later reuse of the game in community engagement activities through a related European project.
2019 – Prototype testing in Spain
The Instituto Valenciano de la Edificación documented a blind playtest of the TripleA-reno board game in its official 2019 activity report.
The prototype was tested without prior instructions, allowing the participants to examine how understandable the gameplay was.
Following the session, the institution prepared observations concerning playability and suggestions for improving the game rules.
This provides evidence that a physical prototype existed and was actively evaluated during the project’s development.
The available institutional report does not establish the exact number of participants or provide standardised educational outcome measures.
15 February 2021 – Housing Europe Home Show
Housing Europe organised an online workshop devoted to demonstrating the Energy Transition Game.
The event involved representatives of housing organisations and professionals interested in sustainable residential renovation.
The game activity addressed two scenarios:
- Low Maintenance Costs: Selecting renovation measures to minimise maintenance requirements.
- Zero-Energy Building: Exploring renovation measures associated with a highly energy-efficient building.
Participants considered energy savings, economics, comfort, installation and maintenance.
The workshop documentation identifies additional points for solutions that achieved a good balance between sustainability and cost.
The event was organised online because of COVID-19 restrictions and demonstrated the game through a facilitated virtual workshop.
This should not be confused with evidence of a separately published digital version of the board game.
The session included a formal introduction, explanation of the game’s purpose, demonstration of its rules, scenario discussion and participant feedback.
2021 – Final project dissemination
The TripleA-reno consortium completed the project in October 2021.
Housing Europe identified the board game as one of the three main results, alongside a combined building-performance labelling system and an online gamified platform.
The Instituto Valenciano de la Edificación also identified the physical game as a tool for participants who preferred direct interaction or were less comfortable with digital technologies.
These institutional reports confirm that the game had progressed beyond a proposed deliverable.
31 March 2022 – Community implementation in Slovenia
The game was subsequently reused within the Horizon 2020 re-MODULEES project.
A community workshop was organised in Zagorje ob Savi, Slovenia, by the Institute for Innovation and Development of the University of Ljubljana, the municipality and a local sustainable energy association.
Participants used the Slovenian version of the TripleA-reno Energy Transition Board Game to discuss practical building renovation scenarios.
The activity encouraged discussion of:
- Possible strategies for renovating existing homes.
- Good and poor renovation practices in the local context.
- Information needed by residents before making renovation decisions.
- Trust between contractors, advisers and consumers.
- Potential support from local organisations and renovation professionals.
The public re-MODULEES report documents the session and includes photographs of the physical game prepared for use.
This is particularly relevant because it demonstrates reuse of the TripleA-reno board game after the original project’s funding period had ended.
Further transfer to European renovation initiatives
Other European projects, including DRIVE 0 and re-MODULEES, subsequently identified the game as a transferable resource for renovation engagement.
DRIVE 0 presented it as a possible tool for the initial consultation stage of residential renovation.
However, inclusion of the game in a project inventory or presentation should not automatically be treated as evidence of completed gameplay sessions.
Evaluation approach
The publicly documented evaluation focuses primarily on usability feedback, formative playtesting, professional discussion and workshop implementation.
The 2019 blind playtest generated suggestions concerning rules and playability.
The 2021 Housing Europe workshop provided opportunities to test the game format and collect participant reactions.
The 2022 Slovenian workshop demonstrated the game’s practical use as a discussion and community engagement tool.
Evidence limitations
- No consolidated participant sample: The number of people who played the game across all activities has not been established.
- No validated pretest-posttest assessment: Objective improvements in renovation knowledge or decision-making skills have not been identified.
- No controlled comparison: The game has not been independently compared with conventional technical training or consultation approaches in the reviewed sources.
- Limited published usability data: The 2019 blind playtest is documented, but its detailed observations and measurements have not been obtained.
- Limited behavioural evidence: No independent evidence establishes that gameplay directly increased real residential renovation activity.
- Unverified long-term outcomes: Continued use is documented, but sustained changes in participants’ knowledge or decisions have not been measured.
- Mixed implementation formats: Online demonstrations and physical workshops should not be treated as methodologically identical.
- Older adult participation: The game was intended partly for residents with lower digital literacy, including older adults, but no specific age-stratified evaluation has been identified.
Overall evaluation status
TripleA-reno provides convincing evidence that an original physical educational board game was developed, tested and used in professional and community settings.
Its reuse in a subsequent European project supports the practical transferability of the educational resource.
Nevertheless, the available evidence concerns development, implementation and engagement rather than independently demonstrated learning gains or behavioural changes.
7. Educational Resources
TripleA-reno developed educational, technical and communication resources intended to support sustainable residential renovation and informed participation by residents, housing organisations and building professionals.
Its principal Board Game-Based Learning output is the Energy Transition Board Game, complemented by information about renovation measures, case studies and digital decision-support tools.
1. Energy Transition Board Game – Official Game Description
Build Up Skills Nederland maintains a detailed description of the EnergieTransitieSpel developed within TripleA-reno.
The resource identifies the game’s educational objectives, target audiences, mechanics and physical components.
It also describes opportunities for adapting and improving Measure Cards, Scenario Cards and Chance Cards.
Energy Transition Board Game – Build Up Skills Nederland
2. Physical Game – ISSO Distribution
The Build Up Skills Nederland website identifies ISSO as the organisation responsible for distributing the physical game.
The website provides an ordering link and a historical listed price of EUR 35.
Energy Transition Game – ISSO Product Listing
Availability: The ordering page could not be opened successfully during the November 2026 review. Current stock, price and ordering functionality have not been verified.
A complete free print-and-play edition has not been identified.
3. Housing Europe – Educational Game Demonstration
Housing Europe organised a virtual workshop on 15 February 2021 to demonstrate the Energy Transition Game.
The accompanying article explains the educational purpose of the game and describes two documented renovation scenarios.
The workshop covered the selection of renovation measures, energy savings, financial considerations, comfort, installation and maintenance.
The article also provides access to a recording of the demonstration.
Housing Europe – Can Renovation with Tenants Be as Easy as a Game?
TripleA-reno Home Show – Energy Transition Game (Video)
4. Instituto Valenciano de la Edificación – Project Results
The Spanish project partner provides an institutional overview of the TripleA-reno outputs.
It identifies the board game as a resource intended particularly for residents who prefer direct discussion or have limited access to digital technologies.
Instituto Valenciano de la Edificación – TripleA-reno Project Results
5. IVE Annual Activity Report 2019 – Prototype Testing
The institution’s 2019 annual report documents a blind playtest of the TripleA-reno board-game prototype, together with feedback concerning its rules and usability.
This is an important primary source confirming that the game was physically tested during development.
IVE Annual Activity Report 2019 – TripleA-reno Board Game Testing (PDF, p. 47)
6. re-MODULEES – Slovenian Community Workshop
The re-MODULEES project published a report documenting the use of the Slovenian version of the Energy Transition Board Game during a community workshop in Zagorje ob Savi on 31 March 2022.
The report describes its role in stimulating discussion about renovation options and local practices.
It includes photographs of the physical game prepared for the activity.
re-MODULEES – D4.8 Slovenian Pilot Market Activation Report (PDF, pp. 12–13)
7. DRIVE 0 – Documentation of the Energy Transition Game
The Horizon 2020 DRIVE 0 project included the TripleA-reno Energy Transition Board Game in its review of educational and communication tools for building renovation.
The report contains a photograph of the complete physical game and discusses its potential application during the initial renovation consultation process.
DRIVE 0 – D4.3 Report on Attractive and Understandable User Information (PDF, p. 22)
8. TripleA-reno Open Gamified Platform
The project developed a complementary online environment combining renovation advice, building performance information, visualisation and user engagement features.
The platform supported communication, co-design and decisions about sustainable residential renovation.
It should be treated as a complementary digital gamification resource rather than as the physical educational board game itself.
TripleA-reno – Digital Platform and Other Public Results (CORDIS)
9. Combined Energy and Comfort Labelling Scheme
TripleA-reno also developed tools for communicating building performance across energy use, indoor environmental quality and occupant wellbeing.
These tools can provide useful background information for educators and professionals discussing the trade-offs represented in the board game.
TripleA-reno – Combined Building Performance Labelling
10. European Commission – Official Project Record
CORDIS records the Energy Transition Board Game as a project demonstrator and provides information about its purpose, target audiences and relationship with the online gamified platform.
TripleA-reno – Official European Commission Project Results
Resource accessibility and licensing
The original TripleA-reno project domain could not be accessed during this review.
However, active partner websites preserve information about the game’s objectives, mechanics and components, and public reports document its development and educational implementation.
The complete physical game has been listed for purchase through ISSO, but current commercial availability has not been independently confirmed.
The Build Up Skills Nederland resource contains an all-rights-reserved notice concerning reproduction and reuse of its content.
No open licence permitting unrestricted reproduction or adaptation of the complete game has been independently verified.
Replicability
The publicly accessible documentation is sufficient to understand the game’s educational approach, main components and the kinds of renovation decisions it represents.
However, independent reproduction requires access to the complete rulebook, cards, board and any necessary permissions.
8. Ludus Magnus Methodological Insight
TripleA-reno is a relevant case for the European Board Game-Based Learning Observatory because it developed an original physical educational game to make residential energy renovation more understandable and participatory.
Its main methodological contribution lies in using scenario cards, renovation measures, chance events and scoring to represent simplified decision-making processes associated with sustainable building improvement.
The game also demonstrates the potential importance of physical tabletop activities within European projects that otherwise rely heavily on digital tools.
Methodological strengths
- Original physical educational game: The Energy Transition Board Game is a completed, identifiable product with documented components and educational purposes.
- Direct relationship between mechanics and learning: Players must select renovation measures under scenario-specific constraints, reproducing the core structure of real renovation decisions.
- Multicriteria optimisation: Participants consider energy, economics, comfort, installation and maintenance rather than concentrating exclusively on one indicator.
- Trade-off awareness: Different scenarios encourage players to examine how priorities influence the suitability of renovation strategies.
- Resident-centred approach: The game incorporates the importance of occupant preferences and needs in the planning process.
- Scenario variability: Eleven Scenario Cards provide a structure for introducing different objectives and constraints.
- Decision-based interaction: Thirty-six Measure Cards support the comparison and combination of possible renovation interventions.
- Uncertainty: Chance Cards introduce an additional element of variability into the decision-making process.
- Scoring and feedback: A score sheet provides a framework for assessing different renovation strategies.
- Inclusive physical format: The game was designed as an offline complement to a digital platform, supporting participation by people less comfortable with technology.
- Professional and community application: The game can be used in educational activities with residents, students, building professionals and housing organisations.
- Development testing: The game underwent a blind playtest that generated feedback about rules and usability.
- Documented implementation: Public workshops and subsequent European project activities provide evidence of real use.
- Post-project transfer: The game was reused in re-MODULEES after the original funding period, demonstrating continued practical relevance.
- Potential for co-creation: The developers invited users to propose new cards, scenarios and reflection questions.
Methodological limitations and considerations
- Limited learning-outcome evaluation: No validated quantitative study has established improvements in knowledge or decision-making skills attributable to the game.
- Incomplete public rule documentation: The complete game rules, all card effects and detailed scoring procedures have not been independently examined.
- Restricted material accessibility: The physical game has been commercially listed, but a complete open print-and-play edition has not been identified.
- Historical information: Renovation technologies, costs, regulations and financial incentives may have changed since the game’s development.
- Simplified technical representation: Actual renovation decisions depend on building-specific conditions that may be difficult to represent fully through cards and scoring.
- Potential facilitator dependence: Non-specialist participants may require explanations of technical concepts and the implications of specific measures.
- Limited information about playtesting: The detailed results of the 2019 usability report have not been made available in the reviewed sources.
- Limited evidence for older adults: Accessibility for residents with lower digital literacy was a design intention, but no specific evaluation of learning outcomes in older adult populations was identified.
- Unverified long-term transfer: The research does not demonstrate that participants subsequently adopted better renovation strategies or carried out additional renovation works.
- Different implementation formats: Facilitated online demonstrations and physical tabletop sessions may differ in participation and learning processes.
- Limited standardised reflection: The developers recognise the possibility of incorporating reflection questions, but a common debriefing protocol has not been verified.
Relationship between mechanics and educational objectives
The Energy Transition Board Game illustrates an important distinction between presenting educational content and requiring players to operate with that content.
Players do not simply answer questions about sustainable renovation. They must select combinations of measures appropriate to a particular scenario.
The core educational challenge therefore involves evaluating alternatives and their consequences within a system of constraints.
For example, a strategy appropriate for minimising maintenance costs may differ from one designed to achieve a Zero-Energy Building.
This makes the game potentially useful for developing awareness of trade-offs and the need to consider several dimensions of sustainability simultaneously.
However, the degree to which individual card effects accurately reproduce real technical and economic relationships cannot be fully assessed without the complete game materials.
Importance of physical accessibility
A particularly distinctive feature of TripleA-reno is the explicit justification for developing an offline board game alongside a digital platform.
The consortium recognised that some residents, including older adults and people with lower digital literacy, may prefer face-to-face interaction and physical learning materials.
From a methodological perspective, this highlights the potential of board games as complementary communication tools in projects where digital participation is not equally accessible to all target groups.
Nevertheless, the availability of an analogue format does not automatically guarantee cognitive, visual, motor or linguistic accessibility. These characteristics require specific user testing.
Board games as consultation instruments
TripleA-reno also illustrates how an educational board game can be integrated into professional consultation.
The game was promoted as an icebreaker for renovation advice and was subsequently used to stimulate discussions among community members and technical experts.
This role differs from classroom instruction in which learning is usually the principal explicit objective.
In advisory contexts, gameplay can help participants articulate priorities, compare possible interventions and identify questions requiring further professional information.
However, the game should not be treated as a substitute for technical building assessment, financial advice or detailed renovation planning.
Transferability between European projects
The reuse of the game in re-MODULEES provides a particularly useful example of exploiting educational outputs beyond the original European project.
The Slovenian workshop demonstrated that the physical game could be introduced into a different project, local setting and language to support discussion about residential renovation.
This is an important indicator of practical transferability, although it does not demonstrate independently measured learning effectiveness.
The game also illustrates how later projects may adopt or extend an existing educational tool rather than developing a new game from the beginning.
Implications for future BGBL initiatives
- Represent authentic professional or everyday decisions through game actions rather than relying exclusively on factual questions.
- Use scenarios with different objectives to encourage comparison of alternative strategies.
- Integrate economic, technical, environmental and social considerations into the same decision-making structure.
- Use physical cards and boards to make complex information easier to organise and discuss.
- Include residents and other end users in the development and testing of educational tools.
- Test whether rules can be understood without extensive prior explanation.
- Provide facilitator guidance for activities involving specialist knowledge.
- Develop structured debriefing questions connecting simulated decisions with real situations.
- Evaluate learning outcomes separately from engagement and satisfaction.
- Assess the accessibility of physical and digital formats with the intended target populations.
- Plan for the maintenance and updating of technical educational content after the funded project ends.
- Preserve complete game rules and materials in accessible repositories to support long-term transfer.
Overall assessment
TripleA-reno provides a substantial example of original physical Board Game-Based Learning within a European sustainable housing initiative.
Its principal strengths are the direct relationship between renovation decisions and gameplay, its multicriteria approach, its intended accessibility for non-digital audiences and its documented use in professional and community settings.
The game has been developed, tested, distributed and reused beyond the original project, providing sufficient evidence for inclusion in the European BGBL Observatory.
Its main limitations concern the restricted availability of complete game materials and the absence of independently validated learning-outcome data.
TripleA-reno is particularly useful as a case study of how physical board games can support informed decision-making, community engagement and the reuse of educational outputs across successive European projects.
