
Integrating Risk Perception and Action to enhance Civil protection-Citizen interaction
RiskPACC developed an original collaborative board game helping citizens, civil protection authorities and community organisations identify gaps between risk perception and preparedness. Players select local resilience objectives, compare technical and organisational solutions, consider contextual factors and receive structured feedback. The Horizon 2020 game was tested in five European workshops, and its official deliverable includes a board, cards, player guidebook, facilitator instructions and observation materials.
1. Project Overview
- Funding programme
- Horizon 2020 – Secure Societies
- Project reference
- 101019707
- Period
- 2021–2024
- Coordinating organisation
- Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft zur Förderung der angewandten Forschung e.V. (Germany)
- Participating countries
- Germany, United Kingdom, Greece, Belgium, France, Czechia, Netherlands, Israel, Italy
- Official project website
- Visit official website
2. Learning Objectives
RiskPACC (Integrating Risk Perception and Action to enhance Civil protection-Citizen interaction) aimed to strengthen disaster resilience by improving communication and cooperation between citizens, civil protection authorities and community organisations.
The project investigated the Risk Perception-Action Gap (RPAG): differences between how people understand risks, the actions they take, and the expectations of citizens and emergency authorities regarding one another’s responsibilities.
As part of its final Physical Risk Pack, the project developed The RiskPACC Game, an original collaborative tabletop game designed to help local stakeholders understand these gaps and select appropriate strategies for addressing them.
Specific learning objectives
- Risk awareness: Recognise the different ways citizens and public authorities perceive disaster risks.
- Risk Perception-Action Gap: Understand the relationship between risk perception, preparedness behaviour and expectations of institutional action.
- Disaster resilience: Explore how local communities can improve their preparedness, response and recovery capabilities.
- Two-way communication: Identify opportunities for dialogue and information exchange between citizens and civil protection authorities.
- Stakeholder understanding: Recognise the priorities, responsibilities, resources and expectations of different local actors.
- Community participation: Encourage the involvement of residents and civil society organisations in identifying risk communication needs.
- Problem identification: Select the most relevant gaps in local risk communication and preparedness.
- Goal formulation: Transform general risk-related problems into specific objectives for a municipality or community.
- Solution awareness: Discover technical and organisational approaches developed through European disaster resilience research.
- Decision-making: Compare potential interventions and select those considered suitable for specific local needs.
- Collaborative reasoning: Exchange arguments and seek agreement among participants with different perspectives.
- Critical evaluation: Examine whether proposed solutions adequately address the selected objectives.
- Contextual understanding: Recognise how geography, institutions, population characteristics and local conditions influence the suitability of interventions.
- Social inclusion: Identify groups that may be excluded by conventional risk communication channels or digital technologies.
- Digital inclusion: Consider barriers affecting people with limited access to or familiarity with digital tools.
- Feedback and reflection: Use external assessments to reconsider and improve proposed solutions.
- Professional cooperation: Strengthen dialogue between municipalities, emergency responders and community representatives.
- Participatory planning: Generate information that may support subsequent local risk management decisions.
Educational focus
The game is organised around three practical questions:
- Which Risk Perception-Action Gaps are particularly relevant to our community?
- Which available solutions could help us address these gaps?
- How should our proposed solutions be assessed and adapted to the local context?
Rather than teaching disaster management through factual quizzes, the game requires participants to identify needs, negotiate priorities and evaluate possible responses.
Its intended outcomes include greater understanding, dialogue and informed planning. The available evaluation does not establish independently measured improvements in participants’ disaster preparedness or risk communication competences.
3. Target Groups
4. Board Games Used or Developed
RiskPACC developed an original physical educational board game called The RiskPACC Game.
The game is the central interactive component of the project’s Physical Risk Pack, a collection of resources intended to support the use of RiskPACC findings by municipalities, civil protection authorities and communities.
Its purpose is to facilitate a structured debate in which local stakeholders identify relevant Risk Perception-Action Gaps and select technical or organisational solutions.
1. The RiskPACC Game
The game brings together representatives of different organisations and community groups around a physical board.
Participants identify shared priorities, discuss alternative interventions and receive feedback on their proposed combination of solutions.
It is a collaborative decision-making activity rather than a competitive game with an individual winner.
Documented characteristics
- Game type: Original collaborative educational board game.
- Format: Physical tabletop game with board, cards, guidebooks and observation materials.
- Players: 4–15.
- Additional participants: At least one trained facilitator and an observer or external assessor.
- Session duration: Approximately 120 minutes, including introduction, gameplay and reflection.
- Core gameplay: Three phases of approximately 20 minutes each.
- Educational setting: Facilitated municipal or community workshops.
- Main objective: Identify local risk communication gaps and select appropriate solutions.
- Scoring: External assessment using a Reaction Card; no conventional competitive scoring system is documented.
- Development: RiskPACC Horizon 2020 consortium, principally documented by Fraunhofer researchers.
Physical board
The board represents a disaster-affected urban environment and contains three pathways extending from a common starting area.
Each pathway provides spaces for a selected goal, proposed solutions, contextual information and external feedback.
The three pathways allow participants to address up to three different local priorities during the same workshop.
Five categories of playing cards
1. Goal Cards
Goal Cards describe problems associated with risk perception, communication and preparedness identified during the project’s research.
Players select one to three goals and personalise them according to the needs of their municipality.
2. Solution Cards
Solution Cards represent technical and conceptual approaches developed or examined by RiskPACC.
Participants compare these options and select interventions that may address their chosen objectives.
3. Joker Cards
Joker Cards allow participants to propose additional solutions not included among the predefined RiskPACC tools.
This prevents the activity from being restricted exclusively to the project’s own technological and organisational results.
4. Context Cards
Context Cards are used to record local circumstances influencing the feasibility or suitability of an intervention.
Relevant considerations may include institutional arrangements, specific hazards and the needs of particular population groups.
5. Reaction Cards
Reaction Cards allow an external assessor to provide written feedback and an evaluation of the proposed solutions.
The published cards include a simple Likert-type rating scale.
The evaluation may identify weaknesses or overlooked contextual factors, allowing participants to revise their proposal.
Main game mechanics
- Collaborative goal selection: Players debate and agree on one to three priority challenges.
- Local problem definition: General Goal Cards are customised to reflect specific community needs.
- Solution selection: Players choose technical and conceptual responses to the selected challenges.
- Card placement: Goals and solutions are organised on the board’s pathways.
- Open solution generation: Joker Cards permit additional proposals outside the predefined options.
- Contextual adaptation: Context Cards capture local conditions and implementation requirements.
- Negotiation and consensus: Stakeholders discuss priorities and attempt to agree on common approaches.
- Presentation: Participants explain their choices to an external assessor.
- Structured feedback: Reaction Cards communicate an assessment of the proposed solutions.
- Revision: Players may add a further Solution Card in response to feedback.
- Participatory documentation: Observers record selected cards, reasoning and discussion outcomes.
Three gameplay phases
Phase I – Choose Your Goals
Players identify the most relevant gaps affecting risk perception and preparedness in their municipality.
They select one to three Goal Cards and make these objectives more specific by describing relevant hazards, circumstances or target populations.
Phase II – Choose Your Solutions
Participants examine available solutions and select those they consider most appropriate for the identified needs.
They may choose project-developed solutions, propose alternatives through Joker Cards and record implementation conditions using Context Cards.
Phase III – Present, Assess and Improve
The group presents its proposed strategy to an external assessor.
The assessor provides feedback using a Reaction Card, including a rating and written observations.
Players may subsequently introduce one additional solution to address an identified weakness.
Game material and documentation
The final deliverable D8.6 includes:
- Introductory presentation slides.
- Physical game board and illustrations of the playing cards.
- Facilitator Guidelines.
- Players’ Guidebook.
- Observer documentation.
- Links to the research and technical resources informing the cards.
RiskPACC – D8.6 Risk Pack Physical Box, Rules and Game Materials (PDF)
RiskPACC – Official Deliverables Repository
Availability and reuse
The game is extensively documented in a public project deliverable, including illustrations of its physical components and complete guidance for facilitating the activity.
However, the availability of separate print-ready files, the distribution of complete physical boxes and the legal conditions for reproducing the game have not been independently established.
While the deliverable is publicly listed on the official website, direct retrieval of its PDF has shown technical errors during the November 2026 review.
Game approach
The appropriate classification is Custom-Designed Educational Games.
The RiskPACC Game was specifically developed to translate the project’s research and practical solutions into a physical collaborative learning and planning activity.
5. BGBL Methodology
RiskPACC developed a collaborative Board Game-Based Learning methodology designed to facilitate dialogue between citizens, civil protection authorities and other local stakeholders.
The physical game translates the project’s research on Risk Perception-Action Gaps into a structured decision-making activity in which participants identify problems, compare potential interventions and receive feedback.
Its educational approach is strongly connected with the principles of co-creation and mutual communication between authorities and communities.
Pedagogical foundations
- Collaborative learning: Participants collectively identify priorities and develop proposed responses.
- Problem-based learning: The activity begins with real or locally relevant problems concerning disaster risk perception and preparedness.
- Stakeholder dialogue: Different organisational and community perspectives contribute to the analysis.
- Participatory decision-making: Players select goals and solutions through discussion and consensus.
- Contextual learning: The game requires participants to adapt general research findings to specific local conditions.
- Knowledge mobilisation: Project research is represented through cards containing identified problems and possible solutions.
- Critical reflection: External assessment creates opportunities to reconsider assumptions and improve proposed interventions.
- Experiential learning: Participants practise selected elements of collaborative planning within a facilitated tabletop activity.
Integration of research into game mechanics
The game is based on several RiskPACC research outputs.
Goal Cards draw on studies examining risk communication and preparedness gaps from the perspectives of civil protection authorities and citizens.
The cards are also connected with the project’s Collaborative Framework, which identifies four interconnected modules:
- Understanding.
- Sharing.
- Relating.
- Building.
Solution Cards introduce the conceptual and technical approaches developed within different work packages.
Consequently, the game’s core mechanism is not the recall of facts but the selection and discussion of potential responses to identified problems.
Facilitated workshop structure
The official Facilitator Guidelines prescribe a two-hour session.
- Opening and introduction – 20 minutes: Facilitators introduce the activity, its objectives and the project background, followed by participant questions.
- Participant introductions – 10 minutes: Players describe their roles and organisational perspectives.
- Preparation – 20 minutes: Participants review the Players’ Guidebook, goals, solutions and playing materials.
- Phase I – 20 minutes: Players agree on their priority Risk Perception-Action Gaps and personalise the Goal Cards.
- Phase II – 20 minutes: Players select potential solutions, consider alternatives and document contextual constraints.
- Phase III – 20 minutes: Players present their proposals, receive external feedback and consider possible improvements.
- Closing discussion – 10 minutes: Participants ask remaining questions and reflect on the activity.
Role of the facilitator
Facilitation is an essential element of the methodology.
The game is expressly designed as a moderated workshop tool rather than an independently playable recreational game.
Facilitators are expected to:
- Prepare the board, cards and introductory presentation.
- Invite appropriate municipal and community stakeholders.
- Explain the Risk Perception-Action Gap and relevant project findings.
- Support participants’ understanding of the different solution options.
- Guide discussion without determining the group’s decisions.
- Ensure that relevant perspectives are considered.
- Keep the activity within the intended session structure.
- Coordinate the external assessment and final reflection.
Role of the observer
At least one observer is recommended to document the selected goals, solutions and principal points of discussion.
The Observer Notebook provides a structured means of recording information that may support subsequent local planning or project evaluation.
The observer may also contribute to the external assessment of proposed solutions.
Feedback and reflection
The third gameplay phase contains an explicit feedback mechanism.
After participants present their proposals, an external assessor considers their relevance and identifies possible shortcomings.
Reaction Cards combine a simple rating with written qualitative observations.
Participants may then revise their approach by adding another Solution Card.
This mechanism creates a direct connection between reflection and modification of the proposed plan.
Methodological transferability
The game can be adapted to different municipalities by selecting locally relevant objectives and documenting specific hazards, institutional arrangements and population characteristics.
Joker Cards allow participants to consider solutions that were not originally developed within RiskPACC.
These features support transfer beyond the original project.
Nevertheless, successful implementation depends on the participation of appropriate stakeholders and facilitators with sufficient knowledge of local disaster risk management.
6. Implementation & Evaluation
RiskPACC was implemented between September 2021 and August 2024 as a Horizon 2020 project coordinated by Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft in Germany.
The consortium combined research institutions, civil protection organisations, municipalities, civil society representatives and technology developers to improve disaster resilience and communication between citizens and public authorities.
Its activities included research on the Risk Perception-Action Gap, co-creation laboratories, development of technical and conceptual solutions, training resources and the Physical Risk Pack.
Development of The RiskPACC Game
The physical board game was developed as a key component of the project’s final dissemination and training resources.
Its development integrated findings from several work packages:
- Research on risk communication gaps identified by civil protection authorities.
- Research on risk perceptions and preparedness needs among citizens.
- The RiskPACC Collaborative Framework.
- Conceptual solutions developed through participatory co-creation.
- Technological solutions intended to improve two-way communication.
These findings informed the design of Goal Cards, Solution Cards and the broader structure of gameplay.
Documented game testing
Deliverable D8.6 reports five workshops in which local stakeholders played the game and provided feedback on its use.
The workshops took place in:
- Heidelberg, Germany.
- Karlsruhe, Germany.
- Setúbal, Portugal.
- Kalamaria, Greece.
- Gdańsk, Poland.
The workshops were associated with the project’s knowledge exchange and field-testing activities, including cooperation with municipalities connected with the European Forum for Urban Security.
The game was intended to help participating stakeholders identify relevant local Risk Perception-Action Gaps and examine possible solutions.
Formative evaluation
The project reports that participants’ feedback contributed to improving the gaming experience.
Its final physical-box deliverable describes the game as positively received and useful for navigating the range of RiskPACC findings and solutions.
However, D8.6 does not provide a complete game-specific evaluation dataset covering all five workshops.
Observation and documentation
The official game methodology includes an Observer Notebook to record:
- Participants’ institutional or community roles.
- Priority goals selected by the group.
- Proposed solutions and alternative approaches.
- Contextual factors affecting implementation.
- Arguments and issues raised during discussion.
- External feedback on proposed interventions.
- Potential implications for subsequent municipal planning.
This makes the game a participatory assessment and knowledge-exchange instrument as well as an educational activity.
External assessment
The third phase of the game incorporates structured feedback from an external assessor.
The assessor evaluates the suitability of the group’s proposed solutions and records observations using a Reaction Card, which includes a simple rating scale.
Participants can subsequently revise their proposal by selecting one additional solution.
This is an evaluation of the proposed disaster risk management strategy within gameplay. It should not be confused with an evaluation of participants’ educational learning outcomes.
Project-wide results
The final CORDIS reporting describes improvements in dialogue and mutual understanding between citizens and civil protection authorities associated with the project’s co-creation activities, tools and board game.
These statements concern the wider intervention and its combined activities.
The published reporting does not isolate the contribution of the game from the other methods implemented by the consortium.
Limitations of the game-specific evaluation
- Participant numbers: The total number of people who played the game across the five workshops has not been independently established.
- Workshop-level information: Detailed participant characteristics and session results are not provided in D8.6.
- Learning outcomes: No validated pretest-posttest assessment of risk knowledge or collaborative competences has been identified.
- Comparison groups: No controlled comparison with a conventional non-game workshop has been established.
- Behavioural transfer: No game-specific evidence demonstrates changes in household preparedness or professional emergency planning.
- Long-term impact: Sustained adoption of solutions selected during gameplay has not been independently measured.
- Facilitator influence: Session outcomes may depend substantially on the facilitator’s preparation and participants’ institutional experience.
- Broader project effects: Results attributed to co-creation workshops or digital tools cannot automatically be attributed to the board game.
Post-project use
The consortium intended The RiskPACC Game to remain available as a method for future municipal workshops after the project ended.
The game’s design allows local communities to adapt the objectives, solution selection and contextual considerations to their own circumstances.
However, independently documented post-project gameplay sessions have not been established during this review.
Overall evaluation status
RiskPACC provides strong evidence that an original physical educational board game was developed, documented and tested in five European workshops.
The game includes structured facilitation, observation, feedback and opportunities for revising decisions.
Its practical usefulness for stimulating discussion is supported by project-reported formative feedback, but its effectiveness in producing independently measurable learning gains or improvements in disaster resilience remains unestablished.
7. Educational Resources
RiskPACC developed a collection of educational, methodological and technical resources designed to support disaster risk communication and collaboration between civil protection authorities and local communities.
The main Board Game-Based Learning output is The RiskPACC Game, included in the Physical Risk Pack.
1. RiskPACC D8.6 – Risk Pack Physical Box
Deliverable D8.6 is the main methodological reference for the physical game.
Published in June 2024, the report describes the game, its objectives, components and implementation procedures.
Its annexes contain:
- Annex A: Introductory presentation.
- Annex B: Physical game board and card illustrations.
- Annex C: Facilitator Guidelines.
- Annex D: Players’ Guidebook.
- Annex E: Observer documentation.
The report is particularly valuable because it explains how the project findings were converted into Goal Cards and Solution Cards.
D8.6 – Risk Pack Physical Box and Game Documentation (PDF)
The deliverable is publicly listed in the project’s official repository, although direct PDF retrieval has shown technical errors during the November 2026 review.
2. RiskPACC – Official Deliverables Repository
The project website provides a catalogue of public reports covering risk perception, citizen engagement, civil protection practices, co-creation methods, technological solutions and training resources.
RiskPACC – Downloads and Public Deliverables
3. RiskPACC Collaborative Framework – D4.4
The Collaborative Framework organises cooperation between citizens and civil protection authorities around four related modules:
- Understanding.
- Sharing.
- Relating.
- Building.
The framework informs the classification of the problems represented in the game’s Goal Cards.
It provides valuable background for facilitators preparing workshops focused on local risk communication.
RiskPACC – Collaborative Framework D4.4
4. RiskPACC Training Material – D4.6
The project developed training resources for civil protection authorities, citizens and other stakeholder groups.
The materials include recommendations for communicating with older adults, children, migrants and other populations with different information needs.
These resources can support the preparation and contextualisation of game sessions.
RiskPACC D4.6 – Training Material (PDF)
5. RiskPACC Lab Methodology and Glossary – D3.4
This deliverable documents the project’s co-creation approach and provides terminology and guidance for organising participatory activities.
It offers background information for educators and facilitators seeking to understand the wider methodological context of the physical game.
RiskPACC – Lab Methodology and Glossary
6. RiskPACC White Paper and Roadmap – D6.4
The White Paper summarises the project’s principal conclusions and recommendations for improving disaster risk communication.
It also explains the purpose of the RiskPACC board game and its role in helping municipalities identify gaps and relevant solutions.
A copy is available through the European Commission’s Civil Protection Knowledge Network.
RiskPACC – White Paper and Roadmap (PDF)
7. RiskPACC Final Results Booklet
The final project booklet presents the principal results, including the Physical Risk Pack and its educational tabletop game.
The booklet describes the game as a resource for increasing understanding of the project’s research and solutions.
RiskPACC – Final Event Results Booklet (PDF)
8. European Commission – Project Results
CORDIS identifies the Risk Pack Physical Box as an official project demonstrator.
The final reporting also confirms development of the physical board game and its contribution to the wider project dissemination activities.
RiskPACC – CORDIS Project Results
Resource accessibility and reuse
The project website and its deliverables catalogue remain accessible.
The D8.6 report contains substantial game documentation, including the physical design and instructions. However, separate production-ready files for all game components have not been verified.
The report’s copyright notice restricts reproduction, modification and redistribution without permission from the project partners.
Consequently, public access to the documentation should not be interpreted as permission to reproduce or commercially distribute the complete physical game.
Replicability
The published methodology provides sufficient information to understand how the game was structured and facilitated.
Practical independent replication would benefit from obtaining the original print-ready files, clarification of reuse rights and appropriate facilitator preparation.
8. Ludus Magnus Methodological Insight
RiskPACC is a valuable case for the European Board Game-Based Learning Observatory because it demonstrates how a physical tabletop game can transform research findings into a structured process of dialogue, negotiation and participatory planning.
The RiskPACC Game provides a practical method for bringing citizens and civil protection professionals together to discuss risk perception, community preparedness and potential interventions.
Its principal methodological contribution lies in the relationship between the game mechanics and the decision-making processes it seeks to support.
Methodological strengths
- Original physical game: RiskPACC developed a completed tabletop resource with an identifiable board, card categories, rules and supporting documentation.
- Research-based design: Goal Cards and Solution Cards are derived from findings and tools developed within the wider project.
- Direct integration of educational objectives: Identifying problems, selecting solutions and evaluating proposals are the core actions required during gameplay.
- Two-way communication: The game creates opportunities for citizens and public authorities to exchange their perspectives.
- Collaborative decision-making: Participants must agree on shared objectives and consider competing approaches.
- Local contextualisation: Players personalise Goal Cards and document additional circumstances using Context Cards.
- Open solution generation: Joker Cards allow participants to introduce alternatives not developed within RiskPACC.
- Structured feedback: Reaction Cards enable an external assessment of proposed solutions.
- Revision after feedback: Participants can improve their proposal by adding an additional solution.
- Explicit facilitation: The deliverable provides guidance for organising, moderating and recording gameplay.
- Participatory research potential: The cards and Observer Notebook help preserve information generated during stakeholder discussions.
- Documented implementation: The game was tested in five municipal workshops.
- Accessibility beyond digital platforms: A physical format offers an alternative means of accessing project results.
- Methodological documentation: The public D8.6 report contains detailed information about the board, cards, player instructions and workshop procedure.
Methodological limitations
- Limited independent educational evaluation: No validated evidence establishes measurable improvements in risk knowledge or collaborative competences.
- Dependence on facilitation: The game was expressly designed as a moderated workshop methodology rather than a self-contained recreational game.
- Limited participant data: Consolidated information on the number and characteristics of participants in the five game-testing workshops is unavailable in D8.6.
- Expert assessment: Reaction Card scores express judgements about proposed solutions rather than objective measurements of learning.
- Potential institutional imbalance: Representatives of public authorities may have greater technical knowledge or decision-making influence than community participants.
- Stakeholder representation: Important viewpoints may remain absent if particular groups are not invited or cannot participate.
- Time restrictions: Complex risk communication problems may require more time than the allocated workshop phases provide.
- Limited outcome attribution: The effects of the game cannot be separated from the wider project’s co-creation activities using the available evidence.
- Restricted reproducibility: Complete production-ready game materials and open reuse rights have not been verified.
- Long-term transfer: No independent evidence demonstrates that the workshop proposals were systematically implemented and produced sustained changes in local preparedness.
Connection between mechanics and learning
RiskPACC is distinctive because its educational structure is organised around a process of collective problem-solving rather than knowledge recall.
The selection of Goal Cards requires participants to identify and agree on relevant local problems.
Solution Cards then provide concrete interventions for comparison and discussion.
Context Cards encourage consideration of the practical circumstances affecting implementation, while Joker Cards prevent discussion from being restricted to a fixed catalogue.
Finally, Reaction Cards introduce external feedback and opportunities for revision.
These mechanisms correspond closely to real activities involved in planning and evaluating local disaster risk communication.
Feedback as a game mechanism
The third phase is a particularly relevant feature.
Instead of ending immediately after participants select their preferred solution, the game requires them to present and defend their choices.
The external assessor considers their suitability and identifies possible shortcomings.
Participants may then modify the proposal by introducing an additional solution.
This creates an explicit cycle of decision, feedback and revision within the game.
However, this process should be understood as formative evaluation of the proposed strategy rather than evidence that the participants have acquired new competences.
Relationship with professional tabletop exercises
The RiskPACC Game shares characteristics with tabletop exercises used in disaster management and organisational training.
However, it has a specific structure involving a physical board, differentiated card functions and successive phases.
Its emphasis is not on simulating the operational response to a disaster in real time, but on selecting and assessing ways to improve risk communication and preparedness.
This distinction separates RiskPACC from emergency simulation games centred on the allocation of operational resources during an unfolding crisis.
Comparison with SAVIT
RiskPACC and SAVIT, developed in the SYNERGIES project, provide two complementary models of professional and community-based tabletop learning.
Both use physical cards, stakeholder collaboration and structured discussion to explore challenges in disaster management.
RiskPACC focuses on identifying Risk Perception-Action Gaps and selecting communication or preparedness solutions.
SAVIT focuses on integrating spontaneous volunteers into disaster management through evolving emergency scenarios.
RiskPACC also incorporates a clearly documented external assessment mechanism through Reaction Cards, whereas SAVIT uses team presentations and collective voting.
These differences provide opportunities to compare the educational functions of consensus-building, external feedback and peer evaluation within tabletop activities.
Implications for future BGBL research
- Use game mechanics that reproduce the cognitive and social processes associated with the intended learning objectives.
- Introduce distinct phases for problem identification, solution generation and evaluation.
- Allow participants to adapt educational content to their own local circumstances.
- Use flexible mechanisms that permit solutions beyond a predefined list.
- Integrate structured feedback and opportunities for revising decisions.
- Document facilitation procedures and the professional background of participants.
- Evaluate participation quality and possible power imbalances between stakeholders.
- Distinguish positive workshop experiences from demonstrated learning gains.
- Consider using participant-generated cards and decisions as qualitative research data.
- Assess whether proposals developed during gameplay are subsequently implemented in real settings.
- Preserve complete printable resources and clarify reproduction permissions to support long-term reuse.
Overall assessment
RiskPACC provides a strong example of an original physical tabletop game developed for collaborative learning and participatory disaster preparedness planning.
Its principal strengths are the direct relationship between game actions and intended decision-making processes, the integration of research-based content, its structured facilitation and external feedback mechanisms, and documented testing in five European workshops.
The game is particularly valuable as an example of how physical tabletop activities can connect professional knowledge with community perspectives.
Its limitations concern the absence of independently verified learning outcomes, the importance of trained facilitators and restrictions on reproducing complete game materials.
For the European BGBL Observatory, RiskPACC offers a relevant case study of collaborative decision-making, structured feedback, participatory research and the use of tabletop games to support dialogue between citizens and public authorities.
