GREEN SURGE

Green Infrastructure and Urban Biodiversity for Sustainable Urban Development and the Green Economy

Democracy & CitizenshipSustainability & EnvironmentTransversal SkillsCustom-Designed Educational Games

GREEN SURGE developed GREEN SURGE City, an original physical board game that simulates urban green infrastructure planning through six stakeholder roles, spatial decisions, negotiation and the allocation of environmental and social benefits. Developed within an FP7 European research project, the game was subsequently used with municipal decision-makers in Finland and examined in a peer-reviewed study on environmental science communication.

1. Project Overview

Funding programme
Seventh Framework Programme (FP7) – Environment
Project reference
603567
Period
2013–2017
Coordinating organisation
University of Copenhagen (Denmark)
Participating countries
24 organisations, including the coordinator, across 11 European countries
Official project website
Visit official website

2. Learning Objectives

GREEN SURGE (Green Infrastructure and Urban Biodiversity for Sustainable Urban Development and the Green Economy) aimed to improve the planning, governance and valuation of urban green infrastructure across European cities.

The project investigated how green spaces, biodiversity, ecosystem services and local communities can contribute to sustainable urban development, climate adaptation and human wellbeing.

Its principal Board Game-Based Learning output was GREEN SURGE City, an original physical educational board game developed as part of a learning module addressing four interconnected topics: green economy, valuation, planning and governance.

Specific learning objectives

  • Urban green infrastructure: Understand the role of interconnected green and blue spaces within urban environments.
  • Ecosystem services: Recognise the environmental, social and economic benefits generated by different forms of urban green infrastructure.
  • Spatial planning: Examine how the location and distribution of green spaces influence their benefits.
  • Urban biodiversity: Explore the relationship between planning decisions, habitat provision and biodiversity.
  • Climate adaptation: Understand how urban green infrastructure can contribute to resilience against extreme weather and climate-related events.
  • Multifunctionality: Recognise that the same urban green space may provide several benefits simultaneously.
  • Trade-offs: Explore situations in which one planning choice produces benefits for certain stakeholders while creating costs or limitations for others.
  • Green economy: Consider the financial and economic dimensions of developing and maintaining urban green infrastructure.
  • Integrated valuation: Distinguish between short-term gains and longer-term environmental and social benefits.
  • Stakeholder perspectives: Understand how local government, businesses, community groups, developers and civil society organisations may have different priorities.
  • Governance: Explore how institutional responsibilities, permissions and political support influence urban planning.
  • Negotiation: Practise discussing alternative plans and obtaining the support required to implement proposals.
  • Collaborative decision-making: Experience the importance of cooperation between stakeholders with different objectives.
  • Strategic thinking: Consider the implications of selecting and locating green infrastructure components within limited urban space.
  • Systems thinking: Recognise the connections between land use, governance, ecosystem services, economic considerations and climate resilience.
  • Critical reflection: Examine differences between individual stakeholder benefits and the overall resilience of the city.
  • Science communication: Make research findings about urban green infrastructure accessible to practitioners, policymakers and students.

Four thematic areas

  1. Green economy: The relationship between urban nature, economic activity and the resources needed to develop green spaces.
  2. Valuation: The different ways environmental, social and economic benefits can be recognised and compared.
  3. Planning: The spatial organisation of urban green infrastructure and its consequences.
  4. Governance: The processes through which different actors negotiate, authorise, develop and maintain green spaces.

Educational scope

GREEN SURGE City was designed primarily for facilitated small-group workshops involving people with an interest in urban green infrastructure but without necessarily possessing extensive specialist expertise.

Its intended educational contribution is the development of understanding through collective action and the exploration of alternative strategies.

These objectives should not be confused with demonstrated learning outcomes. Later research documented positive experiences and exposure to different stakeholder perspectives, but did not establish substantial objective knowledge gains among expert participants.

3. Target Groups

AdultsCommunity GroupsEducators & Professionals

4. Board Games Used or Developed

GREEN SURGE developed an original physical board game called GREEN SURGE City, also written as GreenSurge City.

The game was created within the European research project’s Work Package 4 learning module to support understanding of urban green infrastructure planning, governance, ecosystem service valuation and climate adaptation.

Participants take the roles of stakeholders who must collectively develop green infrastructure within an imaginary city while pursuing different interests and negotiating access to limited urban space.

1. GREEN SURGE City – Urban Green Infrastructure Planning Game

GREEN SURGE City uses a physical representation of an urban environment in which participants can place green infrastructure components.

Players must consider where infrastructure can be built, which actors support the intervention, and which immediate and long-term benefits may result.

The game introduces uncertainty through changes in governance and dramatic climate-related events.

Documented characteristics

  • Game type: Custom-designed physical educational board game.
  • Format: Spatial city-building and stakeholder negotiation game.
  • Learning module: Understanding and Promoting the Values of Urban Green Infrastructure, Deliverable D4.5.
  • Educational focus: Urban green infrastructure, ecosystem services, governance, planning, integrated valuation and climate resilience.
  • Primary audience: Urban planners, policymakers, practitioners and students.
  • Player organisation: Six stakeholder roles, each represented by one player or a team.
  • Player count: Exact recommended total not verified; up to six stakeholder roles are described.
  • Playing time: Not independently verified.
  • Implementation: Developed and tested during the project; subsequently used in a documented Finnish professional workshop in 2018.

Six stakeholder roles

  1. Government: Represents public authorities responsible for aspects of urban planning and governance.
  2. Business: Represents commercial interests and potential economic benefits associated with urban development.
  3. Community: Represents residents and community interests concerning the use of urban space.
  4. Environmentalist: Represents interests related to biodiversity, ecosystems and environmental protection.
  5. Health and Education NGO: Represents social benefits related to public health, education and access to green spaces.
  6. Developer: Represents development pressures and competing demands on urban land.

The roles were selected to represent stakeholders with different interests in the development and use of urban green infrastructure.

The official reporting confirms their existence, but the exact individual role objectives and victory conditions have not been fully examined in the original game materials.

Verified game mechanisms

  1. Role-based objectives: Participants act according to the interests associated with their stakeholder role.
  2. Spatial planning: Players propose green infrastructure in specific areas of an imaginary city.
  3. Construction: During a turn, each role may build up to three green infrastructure components.
  4. Permission and negotiation: Construction requires the approval of other relevant stakeholder roles.
  5. Political support: Players may offer support to infrastructure projects in order to protect them against development pressure.
  6. Competing land uses: Players must negotiate how limited urban space is allocated.
  7. Distribution of benefits: Tokens represent the short-term benefits received during gameplay.
  8. Strategic decision-making: Players must consider the combination of spatial, economic, ecological and social consequences.
  9. Changing governance conditions: The game introduces changes affecting the context in which decisions are made.
  10. Climate-related events: Dramatic weather events test the consequences of earlier planning choices.
  11. Collective outcome evaluation: The resilience of the developed city is assessed at the end of the activity.

Construction and negotiation

The game’s construction mechanism requires participants to obtain agreement from other relevant roles before implementing proposed green infrastructure.

This creates a direct relationship between the physical construction process and the governance challenges represented by the game.

Participants cannot treat spatial planning as a purely individual decision. Their proposals depend on the interests and support of other stakeholders.

Political support and development pressure

The official project report identifies a mechanism through which players can provide political support to protect green infrastructure against the Developer role.

This introduces a form of conflict between long-term environmental and social objectives and competing urban development interests.

Short-term benefits and long-term resilience

During gameplay, benefit tokens represent the distribution of short-term gains.

At the end of the activity, the overall resilience of the city is assessed.

This structure encourages participants to reflect on the differences between the immediate advantages of particular interventions and their wider long-term consequences.

Physical components

The scientific evaluation published in 2023 contains a photograph of GREEN SURGE City in use.

The image confirms a physical city map, role cards and additional tabletop components used by participants during a facilitated workshop.

The complete inventory, number of components, production-ready files and individual card texts have not been independently verified.

Game design and scientific foundations

The game incorporates research findings from GREEN SURGE concerning the relationships between urban biodiversity, ecosystem services, the green economy and participatory governance.

It was conceived as a science communication and educational tool rather than as a conventional commercial board game.

Availability

The original project website previously provided access to the learning module and supporting documents. However, the domain is not currently accessible.

The official CORDIS final report preserves a detailed description of the game, and a peer-reviewed article published in 2023 provides independent evidence of its subsequent use.

The original learning module is bibliographically identified as:

Byrd, C., Andersson, E., Kronenberg, J., Hansen, R., & Buijs, A. (2017). Understanding and Promoting the Values of Urban Green Infrastructure: A Learning Module. GREEN SURGE Deliverable D4.5. University of Copenhagen.

A working public download of the complete board, cards, instructions and facilitator materials has not been confirmed.

GREEN SURGE – Official Game Description in Final Project Reporting

GREEN SURGE City – Published Evaluation and Photograph of Gameplay

Game approach

The appropriate primary classification is Custom-Designed Educational Games.

GREEN SURGE City is an original physical game developed to communicate research findings and structure participatory learning about urban green infrastructure.

5. BGBL Methodology

GREEN SURGE adopted an experiential and participatory Board Game-Based Learning methodology to introduce the complexity of urban green infrastructure planning and governance.

The GREEN SURGE City learning module translates research concerning ecosystem services, urban development, valuation and stakeholder cooperation into a physical city-building activity.

The game is designed primarily for facilitated workshops rather than independent recreational play.

Pedagogical foundations

  • Experiential learning: Players explore planning decisions and their consequences within a simulated urban environment.
  • Role-based learning: Participants adopt different stakeholder perspectives and pursue interests associated with those roles.
  • Collaborative learning: Building infrastructure requires negotiation and cooperation between stakeholders.
  • Spatial reasoning: The physical board makes the distribution and location of urban green spaces visible.
  • Systems thinking: Gameplay connects land use, biodiversity, economic benefits, governance and climate resilience.
  • Problem-based learning: Participants must address competing claims on limited urban space.
  • Negotiation: Players seek the permissions and political support necessary for proposed interventions.
  • Trade-off analysis: Decisions involve immediate benefits, competing priorities and long-term consequences.
  • Reflective learning: The final resilience assessment provides an opportunity to examine the broader consequences of the jointly developed city.
  • Science communication: The activity introduces research findings through direct interaction rather than lectures alone.

Learning module structure

The official project reporting describes the game as the central element of a learning module introducing four topics:

  1. Green economy.
  2. Valuation.
  3. Planning.
  4. Governance.

The module was designed to work best as a facilitated workshop for small groups interested in urban green infrastructure.

Documented game-based learning process

  1. Introduction: A facilitator introduces urban green infrastructure and the purpose of the learning activity.
  2. Role allocation: Participants receive stakeholder roles with different perspectives and objectives.
  3. Spatial analysis: Players examine the imaginary city and possible locations for green infrastructure.
  4. Project proposals: Participants select green infrastructure components they wish to construct.
  5. Stakeholder negotiation: Players obtain the permissions and support required by the game’s rules.
  6. Infrastructure construction: Approved components are placed in the city.
  7. Benefit allocation: Tokens represent the distribution of short-term benefits.
  8. Changes and events: Governance developments and climatic events influence the simulated city.
  9. Collective assessment: The overall resilience of the city is evaluated.
  10. Reflection: Participants can connect the observed outcomes with the planning, valuation and governance concepts introduced during the activity.

The sequence above combines the documented game structure with its intended educational application. It should not be treated as a complete reconstruction of the original rulebook.

Facilitation

Facilitation is a significant element of the game’s methodology.

In the documented Finnish implementation, researchers introduced the research topic, explained the rules, facilitated discussion and also participated as players.

The facilitators helped participants interpret green infrastructure planning decisions and contributed specialist knowledge during the activity.

Role-taking versus professional identity

Participants are assigned roles within the game rather than necessarily playing from their own professional positions.

This creates opportunities for perspective-taking but may also reduce the relevance of the activity for experts who already possess extensive professional experience.

In the published Finnish evaluation, some participants stated that they would have gained more from the activity if others had engaged more seriously with their assigned roles. One participant considered that using actual professional perspectives might have supported deeper knowledge exchange.

Reflection and evaluation

The original game includes a final assessment of the resilience of the city created through play.

This provides a basis for examining which planning decisions were beneficial, which trade-offs emerged and how political or development pressures affected the final configuration.

The published 2018 Finnish implementation also collected post-activity questionnaires and conducted follow-up interviews.

However, the complete original facilitator handbook and any prescribed post-game debriefing questions have not been independently examined.

Methodological transferability

GREEN SURGE City illustrates how spatially explicit tabletop games can be used in professional workshops addressing environmental planning and complex stakeholder relationships.

The format could inform other educational activities involving urban sustainability and participatory land-use decisions.

Independent replication nevertheless requires access to the original materials, appropriate facilitator preparation and consideration of the local planning context.

6. Implementation & Evaluation

GREEN SURGE was implemented between November 2013 and October 2017 as a European Seventh Framework Programme (FP7) project coordinated by the University of Copenhagen, Denmark.

The consortium brought together 24 organisations from 11 European countries, combining research on urban biodiversity, ecosystem services, green infrastructure planning, environmental valuation and participatory governance.

Its activities included European comparative studies, Urban Learning Labs, practitioner guidelines and a physical educational board game called GREEN SURGE City.

Development and implementation of GREEN SURGE City

GREEN SURGE City was developed within Work Package 4, as part of Deliverable D4.5, Understanding and Promoting the Values of Urban Green Infrastructure: A Learning Module.

The game was designed to help practitioners, policymakers and students explore urban green infrastructure through role-based decisions, spatial planning, stakeholder negotiation and the consequences of development choices.

Its design incorporates four interconnected educational themes:

  • Green economy.
  • Environmental and economic valuation.
  • Urban green infrastructure planning.
  • Participatory governance.

The European Commission’s final project report confirms that the game was developed and tested as a science communication and professional learning tool.

The learning module was intended primarily for small facilitated workshops involving participants interested in urban green infrastructure, particularly those without comprehensive specialist expertise.

Implementation beyond the original project

A particularly important source of independent evidence is the scientific study by Jämsä and colleagues, published in Applied Environmental Education & Communication in July 2023.

The study examined three approaches to environmental science communication for expert audiences: board-game-based communication, virtual reality and an art-based scenario workshop.

GREEN SURGE City was the physical game used in the board-game intervention.

November 2018 – Professional workshop in Helsinki, Finland

The game was used in an environmental science communication activity involving municipal decision-makers and planning professionals from the Helsinki metropolitan area.

Documented characteristics

  • Date: November 2018.
  • Location: Helsinki metropolitan area, Finland.
  • Participants: 10 municipal councillors and planning civil servants.
  • Game groups: Three parallel groups.
  • Completed questionnaires: 9.
  • Follow-up interviews: 4.
  • Method: Facilitated role-based board-game session.
  • Game duration: Not independently specified in the publication.
  • Research design: Exploratory assessment of science communication approaches using surveys and qualitative interviews.

Workshop procedure

  1. Research introduction: A researcher presented information about urban green infrastructure planning.
  2. Role allocation: Participants randomly selected role cards representing different stakeholders.
  3. Game explanation: Researchers explained the game and its rules.
  4. Gameplay: Participants developed an imaginary city while attempting to achieve objectives associated with their roles.
  5. Negotiation: Players discussed the placement of green infrastructure and the competing interests represented by different roles.
  6. Facilitation: Researchers supported the activity and participated as players.
  7. Immediate evaluation: Participants completed a questionnaire about their experiences.
  8. Follow-up evaluation: Selected participants took part in semi-structured interviews.

The activity was conducted after the formal completion of GREEN SURGE. It therefore provides evidence of the subsequent use of an educational output originally developed through the European project.

Evaluation instruments

The scientific study used a questionnaire based on the science communication framework proposed by Burns and colleagues.

The questionnaire contained 15 closed-ended statements rated on a five-point Likert scale, addressing aspects such as enjoyment, awareness, interest and understanding.

Follow-up semi-structured interviews were conducted to obtain more detailed information about participants’ experiences.

The researchers used qualitative thematic analysis, supported by ATLAS.ti, to organise interview findings into 17 categories grouped under four principal dimensions:

  1. Enjoyment: Participants’ experiences of the atmosphere, novelty and emotional aspects of the activity.
  2. Usability: Perceived ease of use and usefulness of the information communicated.
  3. Sociability: Interaction with other participants, facilitation and group dynamics.
  4. Learning: Perceived changes in awareness, understanding, interest and opinions.

The same broad evaluation framework was used for the three environmental communication approaches, although the activities addressed different environmental topics.

Results – Enjoyment

All nine respondents to the GREEN SURGE City questionnaire agreed that they enjoyed the board-game activity.

Participants generally regarded the activity as a pleasant and engaging way to approach environmental research.

The relaxed atmosphere appeared to support participation and discussion.

Results – Usability

Most participants regarded the game as reasonably easy to understand and play.

Only one participant specifically reported that the game was too complex.

However, the researchers found that simplifying research information for the game could reduce its perceived usefulness for experienced professionals.

Some participants considered the content insufficiently detailed for their existing level of expertise.

Results – Sociability

Discussion with other participants and the researchers was regarded as one of the most valuable aspects of the experience.

Participants highlighted the opportunity to encounter different professional perspectives and discuss decisions concerning urban green infrastructure.

The study also identified the importance of the role-playing mechanism.

Some participants considered that their peers did not take their assigned roles seriously enough, reducing the depth of discussion.

One interviewee suggested that allowing participants to contribute from their actual professional positions might have produced more meaningful knowledge exchange.

Results – Learning

Only one of the nine survey respondents agreed that the game helped them understand scientific knowledge better.

This result should be interpreted in the context of the participants’ already substantial expertise in environmental and urban planning matters.

Although relatively few participants reported substantial new knowledge, several interviewees described gaining additional perspectives on urban green infrastructure and the consequences of different planning decisions.

The researchers concluded that the approaches studied were more suitable for encouraging dialogue and understanding different viewpoints than for transmitting extensive new scientific knowledge to experts.

Role of facilitation

Researchers played an active role in introducing the topic, explaining the rules and moderating the workshop.

Their specialist comments were considered an important source of additional information by several participants.

This finding indicates that the educational experience depended not only on game mechanics but also on professional interaction and expert facilitation.

Relationship with the wider GREEN SURGE project

The project also established Urban Learning Labs in Bari, Berlin, Edinburgh, Ljubljana and Malmö.

These laboratories supported broader processes of knowledge exchange between researchers and urban stakeholders.

However, the existence of five Urban Learning Labs should not be interpreted as evidence that GREEN SURGE City was played in each of those cities.

The independently documented 2018 gameplay session took place in Finland and was part of a separate science communication study.

Limitations of the evaluation

  • Small sample: The board-game activity involved ten participants, with nine questionnaire responses and four interviews.
  • Specialised audience: Participants already possessed substantial professional expertise.
  • Non-randomised intervention: There was no random allocation to equivalent game and non-game learning conditions.
  • Different comparison activities: The broader study examined virtual reality and art-based workshops addressing different environmental subjects, not equivalent interventions teaching the same content.
  • Self-reported outcomes: The questionnaire and interviews primarily measured participant perceptions.
  • No objective learning test: Validated pretest-posttest assessment of knowledge or planning competence was not reported.
  • No behavioural follow-up: The study did not establish subsequent changes in municipal planning decisions attributable to gameplay.
  • Researcher involvement: Researchers both facilitated and participated in gameplay, potentially influencing discussion.
  • Role engagement: Differences in how seriously participants adopted their assigned roles affected the experience.
  • Limited generalisability: Findings from a small group of Finnish municipal professionals may not apply to students, community groups or other professional populations.
  • Incomplete game documentation: The original production-ready materials and detailed facilitator instructions have not been independently examined.

Overall evaluation status

GREEN SURGE provides strong evidence of the development of an original physical educational board game, while the 2018 Finnish implementation and 2023 scientific publication demonstrate its subsequent use and exploratory evaluation.

The available findings support its value as an engaging method for encouraging dialogue, stakeholder perspective-taking and reflection on urban green infrastructure.

However, they do not demonstrate substantial objective knowledge gains or improved real-world planning performance.

The distinction between dialogue-oriented learning and factual knowledge transmission is particularly relevant when evaluating the game’s suitability for experienced professional audiences.

Main scientific reference

Jämsä, J., Sandström, V., Holopainen, J., Juhola, S., Kalliokoski, T., Korhonen-Kurki, K., Lyytikäinen, V., Mattila, O., Pietikäinen, J., & Soini, K. (2023). Environmental communication for expert audiences: Experimenting three approaches. Applied Environmental Education & Communication, 22(2), 61–75.

Scientific Evaluation – Journal Article

Open-Access Full Article (PDF)

7. Educational Resources

GREEN SURGE developed educational and methodological resources to support the planning, governance and valuation of urban green infrastructure.

Its main Board Game-Based Learning resource is GREEN SURGE City, an original physical board game accompanied by a learning module intended for practitioners, policymakers and students.

The project also published research reports, planning and governance guides, policy recommendations and materials supporting knowledge exchange between researchers and urban stakeholders.

1. GREEN SURGE City – Educational Board Game and Learning Module

The original educational resource is documented in Deliverable D4.5, Understanding and Promoting the Values of Urban Green Infrastructure: A Learning Module.

The module uses GREEN SURGE City to introduce four central themes:

  • Green economy.
  • Integrated environmental valuation.
  • Urban green infrastructure planning.
  • Participatory governance.

The physical game allows participants to develop an imaginary city, negotiate green infrastructure decisions, balance costs and benefits and experience the effects of climate-related events.

Players adopt different stakeholder roles and must collaborate or negotiate to obtain permission for proposed interventions.

According to the final project report, the learning module was published online and distributed as part of the GREEN SURGE educational resources.

Current availability: An online edition of the learning module remains listed through the University of Copenhagen’s electronic publication platform. The viewer page is accessible, but the complete contents and production-ready game materials could not be independently inspected during this review.

GREEN SURGE – Learning Module D4.5 (University of Copenhagen Digital Publication)

Bibliographic reference: Byrd, C., Andersson, E., Kronenberg, J., Hansen, R., & Buijs, A. (2017). Understanding and Promoting the Values of Urban Green Infrastructure: A Learning Module. GREEN SURGE Deliverable D4.5. University of Copenhagen.

2. Scientific Evaluation of GREEN SURGE City – Jämsä et al. (2023)

Jämsä and colleagues published an independent scientific study examining the experiences of environmental experts participating in different science communication activities.

GREEN SURGE City was used in the board-game intervention.

The article documents:

  • Gameplay with municipal decision-makers in Finland.
  • The use of three parallel game groups.
  • Random allocation of stakeholder role cards.
  • Researcher-led introduction and facilitation.
  • Questionnaires and follow-up interviews.
  • Participant experiences of enjoyment, usability, sociability and learning.
  • Strengths and weaknesses of using a simplified game with expert audiences.

The publication includes a photograph showing the game board and physical components in use.

Environmental Communication for Expert Audiences – Scientific Publication (2023)

Open-Access Scientific Article – Aalto University (PDF)

3. GREEN SURGE D4.4 – Guide to Valuation and Integration of Different Valuation Methods

This guide provides methodological recommendations concerning the assessment and comparison of urban green infrastructure benefits.

It addresses monetary and non-monetary valuation methods and explains why different contexts require different approaches.

The guide provides background for understanding the trade-offs and benefit allocation represented within GREEN SURGE City.

It is a complementary research and professional guidance resource, not a separate educational board game.

GREEN SURGE D4.4 – Guide to Valuation and Integration of Different Valuation Methods

4. Urban Green Infrastructure Planning – A Guide for Practitioners

GREEN SURGE developed practical guidance for creating connected, multifunctional urban green infrastructure.

The guide addresses planning principles including:

  • Integration of green and grey infrastructure.
  • Ecological and social connectivity.
  • Multifunctionality of urban green spaces.
  • Social inclusion.
  • Cooperation between public authorities and other stakeholders.
  • Long-term planning and management.

These topics complement the educational challenges represented by the board game.

Urban Green Infrastructure Planning – A Guide for Practitioners

5. Innovative Governance for Urban Green Infrastructure – A Guide for Practitioners

The project produced a guide examining how citizens, community organisations, businesses and public institutions can participate in the development and maintenance of urban green spaces.

Its content is directly relevant to GREEN SURGE City’s stakeholder roles and negotiation mechanics.

Topics include citizen-led initiatives, collaborative governance, business participation, social inclusion and the long-term sustainability of green space management.

Innovative Governance for Urban Green Infrastructure – Practitioner Guide

6. GREEN SURGE – Project Synthesis and Handbook

The project produced an extensive synthesis of its research findings, policy recommendations and practical guidance.

This publication explains how urban green infrastructure can connect people, nature and the green economy in sustainable cities.

It provides theoretical and practical background for interpreting the environmental, social and economic dimensions represented in the game.

Urban Green Infrastructure: Connecting People and Nature for Sustainable Cities

7. European Commission – Final Project Reporting

The CORDIS final report contains the most detailed directly readable public description of GREEN SURGE City identified in this review.

Its section 3.5.5 explains:

  • The four themes of the learning module.
  • The game’s intended audience.
  • The six stakeholder roles.
  • Construction and permission requirements.
  • The use of political support.
  • The allocation of short-term benefit tokens.
  • The final assessment of urban resilience.
  • The game’s relationship with GREEN SURGE research.

GREEN SURGE – CORDIS Final Project Report

8. Forest Research – Institutional Project Resources

Forest Research, a partner in the project, maintains an active institutional page explaining GREEN SURGE’s objectives, research activities and findings.

The page addresses knowledge exchange, participatory governance, environmental planning and the project’s 24-partner consortium.

It also documents the challenges of communicating scientific concepts in forms that urban practitioners can understand and apply.

Forest Research – GREEN SURGE Project and Results

9. ICLEI Europe – GREEN SURGE Project Overview

ICLEI Europe maintains an active record of the project’s objectives and cooperation with municipalities.

It explains the development of Urban Learning Labs and the involvement of researchers and local stakeholders in green infrastructure planning.

ICLEI Europe – GREEN SURGE

10. Scientific Synthesis of GREEN SURGE

Pauleit and colleagues published a scientific review summarising the project’s contributions to urban green infrastructure research and practice.

The publication provides relevant background on ecosystem services, governance, biodiversity, planning and the opportunities and limitations of transdisciplinary research.

Pauleit, S., et al. (2019). Advancing urban green infrastructure in Europe: Outcomes and reflections from the GREEN SURGE project. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening, 40, 4–16.

GREEN SURGE – Scientific Synthesis (2019)

Scientific Synthesis – University Repository (PDF)

Resource accessibility and licensing

The original project domain, greensurge.eu, is no longer reliably accessible.

However, CORDIS, Forest Research, ICLEI Europe, university repositories and the University of Copenhagen’s digital publication platform preserve substantial project information.

The learning module and other guides remain indexed in an electronic publication viewer.

The complete game board, role cards, benefit tokens, event materials and printing instructions have not been independently retrieved as a reusable package.

The open licence applying to the 2023 scientific article should not automatically be interpreted as permission to reproduce the original game’s physical materials.

Replicability

The public documentation provides sufficient information to analyse the game’s educational concept and principal mechanics.

However, accurate independent reproduction would require the complete rules, role objectives, scoring system, event materials and game components.

Until these materials can be verified, GREEN SURGE City should be classified as a documented and implemented physical board game with partially accessible replication resources.

8. Ludus Magnus Methodological Insight

GREEN SURGE is a valuable case for the European Board Game-Based Learning Observatory because it demonstrates how a physical board game can represent complex relationships between urban planning, stakeholder interests, environmental benefits and collective resilience.

GREEN SURGE City’s principal methodological contribution lies in the integration of spatial decision-making, asymmetric stakeholder roles, negotiation and the comparison of immediate and long-term outcomes.

The subsequent scientific evaluation also provides important evidence about the opportunities and limitations of using educational board games with experienced professional audiences.

Methodological strengths

  1. Original physical educational game: GREEN SURGE developed an identifiable board game with documented roles, construction rules, negotiation requirements and benefit allocation.
  2. Research-based design: The game translates findings about biodiversity, ecosystem services, valuation and governance into a physical learning environment.
  3. Spatial representation: The game board allows participants to explore how the location and distribution of green infrastructure influence urban development.
  4. Asymmetric stakeholder perspectives: Six different roles represent potentially competing interests in the planning and management of urban green spaces.
  5. Negotiation as a core mechanic: Players must obtain permission from relevant stakeholders before constructing certain infrastructure components.
  6. Interdependent decisions: Individual players cannot implement all desired interventions without considering the positions of other participants.
  7. Physical construction: The placement of green infrastructure components makes planning decisions visible and supports discussion of spatial consequences.
  8. Governance representation: Political support can influence the protection of infrastructure against competing development interests.
  9. Multidimensional benefits: Players must consider social, environmental and economic consequences rather than focusing exclusively on one objective.
  10. Immediate versus long-term outcomes: Short-term benefit tokens are complemented by an assessment of the city’s overall resilience.
  11. External environmental challenges: Climate-related events introduce uncertainty and consequences that depend on previous planning decisions.
  12. Perspective-taking: Role allocation creates opportunities to examine stakeholder priorities different from participants’ usual professional positions.
  13. Facilitated professional dialogue: Researchers can use the game to stimulate discussions between practitioners from different disciplines.
  14. Documented implementation: The game was used in a professional workshop after the European project ended.
  15. Peer-reviewed evaluation: A subsequent scientific study provides qualitative and questionnaire-based evidence concerning the experience of playing the game.
  16. Evidence of limitations: The research identifies situations in which the game’s simplification and assigned roles reduce its usefulness for expert audiences.

Methodological limitations and considerations

  1. Small evaluation sample: The documented Finnish intervention involved ten participants, nine questionnaire responses and four interviews.
  2. Limited factual learning: Only one of nine respondents reported that the game improved their understanding of the scientific knowledge presented.
  3. Expert audience mismatch: Simplified game content may provide insufficient new information to experienced professionals.
  4. Variable role engagement: Some participants did not adopt their assigned stakeholder roles seriously enough to support meaningful discussion.
  5. Potentially reduced professional knowledge exchange: Fictional roles may prevent experts from contributing fully from their actual areas of expertise.
  6. Facilitator dependence: Researchers’ explanations and professional knowledge were important sources of information during the workshop.
  7. Researcher participation: Facilitators also acted as players, potentially influencing group interaction and decisions.
  8. Game simplification: Complex planning and ecosystem relationships are represented through a limited number of roles, components and rules.
  9. Limited educational outcome evidence: The scientific evaluation did not include validated pretest-posttest measures of knowledge or professional competences.
  10. No demonstrated behavioural transfer: Subsequent changes in participants’ real urban planning practices were not established.
  11. Unclear standardised debriefing: The complete original facilitator guidance has not been independently examined.
  12. Restricted replication materials: The original game components and printing instructions are not available as a verified complete package.
  13. Contextual differences: Experiences with Finnish municipal experts may not generalise to students, residents or less experienced professional groups.

Connection between game mechanics and educational objectives

GREEN SURGE City provides a strong example of educational content being embedded within game actions rather than presented only through quizzes or explanatory text.

The spatial planning objective is represented by constructing green infrastructure in an imaginary city.

The governance objective is represented by the need to obtain permission and political support from other stakeholders.

The valuation objective is represented by the allocation of short-term benefits and the evaluation of overall city resilience.

Climate adaptation is represented through environmental events that test the consequences of earlier planning decisions.

This alignment between mechanics and educational objectives is a principal methodological strength.

However, mechanical alignment should be distinguished from empirical effectiveness. A well-structured simulation does not automatically produce measurable learning gains.

Role-playing versus professional knowledge exchange

One of the most interesting findings of the 2023 scientific evaluation concerns stakeholder role adoption.

The game assigns participants roles such as developer, government representative or environmental organisation member.

This approach can encourage perspective-taking, particularly when participants are unfamiliar with the priorities of different stakeholders.

However, the Finnish evaluation revealed an important limitation.

Some participants considered that others did not take their assigned roles sufficiently seriously, reducing the depth of negotiation.

One interviewee suggested that participants could have contributed more useful knowledge by acting from their actual professional perspectives.

This raises an important design question: should educational games for expert audiences assign fictional roles or allow participants to contribute using their existing professional expertise?

The answer may depend on the learning objective.

Fictional role allocation may be preferable when the objective is to understand unfamiliar interests, practise perspective-taking or explore conflicts between stakeholders.

Authentic professional participation may be preferable when the objective is to exchange specialised information, identify practical solutions or develop realistic interorganisational proposals.

Both approaches have educational potential, but they should not be treated as interchangeable.

Different outcomes for novice and expert audiences

GREEN SURGE City was originally designed as part of a learning module primarily intended for participants interested in urban green infrastructure but not necessarily possessing extensive specialist knowledge.

The later Finnish study involved municipal professionals with considerable prior experience.

This difference in target audience is relevant when interpreting the results.

Experts may already understand the fundamental principles represented in the game, reducing the opportunity to acquire new factual knowledge.

Nevertheless, they may still benefit from encountering unfamiliar stakeholder perspectives or discussing established problems in a different format.

Consequently, the effectiveness of a professional educational board game should not be evaluated exclusively through factual knowledge acquisition.

Measures of perspective-taking, quality of dialogue, collaborative reasoning and awareness of competing stakeholder priorities may also be appropriate.

Social interaction as the principal educational contribution

The 2023 evaluation found that dialogue with researchers and other participants was often perceived as more valuable than the simplified information presented within the activity.

This distinction has important methodological implications.

The physical board game may function as a structured social environment in which participants share their expertise, negotiate priorities and become aware of alternative interpretations.

In that context, the educational mechanism is not necessarily the direct transmission of information from the game to the player.

It may instead involve the exchange of knowledge between players, facilitated by a shared decision-making task.

However, the actual quality of this exchange depends on who participates, how roles are interpreted and how the discussion is facilitated.

Individual benefits versus collective resilience

Another distinctive feature is the relationship between immediate stakeholder benefits and the final resilience of the city.

During gameplay, tokens represent short-term benefits obtained through particular interventions.

At the end, the collective outcome is assessed through an evaluation of overall urban resilience.

This creates an opportunity for participants to examine how individual or sector-specific gains may differ from the long-term performance of the urban system.

The distinction is directly relevant to sustainability education, where short-term economic or political interests may conflict with longer-term environmental and social objectives.

The importance of facilitation

The scientific study identified the contributions of researchers and facilitators as particularly important.

Several participants considered expert commentary to be a principal source of additional information.

This suggests that the game should not be evaluated solely as an isolated physical product.

The educational intervention comprises the game, the scientific introduction, the facilitator’s contributions, the interaction between players and the reflection generated during and after gameplay.

For future evaluations, these components should be documented separately whenever possible.

Comparison with other European BGBL projects

GREEN SURGE City shares methodological characteristics with urbEN, developed within LOTUS, and HEATopoly, developed within R-ACES.

These games use physical spatial representations, stakeholder interests and negotiation to address environmental or territorial decisions.

However, GREEN SURGE City is distinctive because its scientific evaluation directly questions the appropriateness of fictional stakeholder roles for expert participants.

The comparison with SAVIT, developed within SYNERGIES, is particularly informative.

In SAVIT, participants generally work from their real professional positions while jointly examining disaster management problems.

GREEN SURGE City uses assigned stakeholder roles to structure competing interests in urban planning.

This contrast illustrates two possible approaches to professional game-based learning: simulation of unfamiliar perspectives and exchange of actual professional expertise.

Implications for future BGBL research

  • Align game mechanics with the actual decisions and interactions underlying the intended educational objectives.
  • Use spatial game boards to make territorial relationships and land-use conflicts visible.
  • Incorporate negotiation when governance and stakeholder cooperation are central learning objectives.
  • Distinguish short-term benefits from longer-term collective outcomes.
  • Test the effectiveness of assigned roles separately with novice and expert audiences.
  • Consider allowing professionals to contribute from their real institutional positions when knowledge exchange is the principal objective.
  • Document the extent to which participants engage seriously with their roles.
  • Assess the educational contribution of dialogue rather than relying only on factual knowledge tests.
  • Separate participant enjoyment, perceived usefulness and actual learning outcomes.
  • Record facilitator interventions and examine their influence on participants’ understanding.
  • Measure changes in perspective-taking, stakeholder understanding and collaborative reasoning where appropriate.
  • Consider whether simplified game systems preserve the essential complexity required by professional audiences.
  • Use debriefing to connect simulated decisions with real planning procedures and contextual constraints.
  • Preserve complete game materials and clarify reuse permissions for long-term educational replication.

Overall assessment

GREEN SURGE provides a substantial example of original physical Board Game-Based Learning for urban sustainability and participatory planning.

Its principal strengths are the integration of spatial construction, asymmetric stakeholder roles, negotiation, benefit allocation and environmental consequences into a coherent educational simulation.

Its subsequent use in Finland and peer-reviewed scientific evaluation provide valuable evidence of participant experiences.

The game was regarded as enjoyable and useful for dialogue, but the available research does not demonstrate substantial factual learning gains among experienced professionals.

For the European BGBL Observatory, GREEN SURGE is particularly relevant as a case study of role-based environmental simulation, collaborative spatial planning and the distinction between knowledge transmission and professional dialogue.

Resumen de privacidad

Esta web utiliza cookies para que podamos ofrecerte la mejor experiencia de usuario posible. La información de las cookies se almacena en tu navegador y realiza funciones tales como reconocerte cuando vuelves a nuestra web o ayudar a nuestro equipo a comprender qué secciones de la web encuentras más interesantes y útiles. Ver política de Cookies