
SmartH2O: an ICT Platform to leverage on Social Computing for the efficient management of Water Consumption
SmartH2O developed DROP!, an original physical card game connected to Drop!TheQuestion, a mobile quiz about sustainable water consumption. Using a push-your-luck mechanism, numbered cards, penalty cards and QR challenges, the game encouraged family participation in water-saving activities. The FP7 project produced 2,500 copies and distributed them through pilot programmes in Spain and Switzerland, with documented digital engagement and user feedback.
1. Project Overview
- Funding programme
- Seventh Framework Programme (FP7) – ICT
- Project reference
- 619172
- Period
- 2014–2017
- Coordinating organisation
- Scuola Universitaria Professionale della Svizzera Italiana (SUPSI - Switzerland)
- Official project website
- Visit official website
2. Learning Objectives
SmartH2O aimed to promote more sustainable household water consumption through smart metering, personalised consumption feedback, social engagement and gamification.
Within this wider initiative, the consortium developed DROP!, an original physical card game connected to the Drop!TheQuestion mobile application and the SmartH2O consumer portal.
The game was designed primarily as an engaging entry point into water conservation education rather than as a standalone instructional simulation.
Specific learning and engagement objectives
- Water conservation awareness: Encourage children and families to recognise the importance of reducing unnecessary water consumption.
- Sustainable household habits: Introduce examples of responsible and wasteful everyday water-use behaviours.
- Environmental responsibility: Promote conversation about the consequences of water consumption.
- Family participation: Encourage children and parents to engage together in an activity connected with sustainability.
- Recognition of good practices: Use illustrated cards to distinguish water-saving actions from wasteful behaviour.
- Water literacy: Provide access to questions and information about water resources, consumption and conservation through the digital companion.
- Critical awareness: Encourage participants to reflect on domestic habits and consider possible changes.
- Risk assessment: Practise elementary decisions involving probability, uncertainty and potential rewards through the card game’s push-your-luck mechanism.
- Communication: Encourage interaction, anticipation and discussion during family gameplay.
- Digital participation: Introduce the use of QR codes and a mobile application as extensions of a physical game.
- Motivation: Use entertainment and rewards to encourage voluntary engagement with water-saving content.
- Behavioural engagement: Connect playful activities with real consumption feedback and household water-saving goals.
Educational integration
DROP! combines three levels of engagement:
- Physical game: A family-oriented card game based on risk-taking and challenges, with illustrations contrasting water-saving and wasteful actions.
- Digital learning: Drop!TheQuestion allows players to answer water-related questions and recover points associated with negative cards.
- Everyday application: The SmartH2O consumer portal displays household water consumption, recommendations, goals, points and rewards.
The primary learning purpose is associated with the complete physical-digital experience. The physical card game alone does not require players to demonstrate water conservation knowledge in order to win.
Target audiences
The card game was designed for three to six players, especially primary school children and their families. It was also used in school-based outreach activities.
The intended educational benefits should be distinguished from measured outcomes. The project evaluated digital engagement and user acceptance, but did not establish the independent educational effect of the physical card game.
3. Target Groups
4. Board Games Used or Developed
SmartH2O developed an original physical card game called DROP!, complemented by a mobile quiz application called Drop!TheQuestion.
The game was developed within the project’s social gaming work package. Spartaco Albertarelli contributed to the game design, while Moonsubmarine produced the physical edition.
1. DROP! – Physical Water Conservation Card Game
DROP! is a family-oriented card game based on a push-your-luck mechanism, with bidding and challenges between players.
The game’s narrative features Lily, a young girl who uses water responsibly, and her clumsy monster friend, whose actions waste water.
Players earn points through positive cards featuring Lily, while Monster Cards introduce penalties. A digital extension allows participants to transform negative outcomes by answering questions about water.
Documented game characteristics
- Game type: Custom-designed physical educational and persuasive card game.
- Players: 3–6.
- Primary audience: Primary school children and families.
- Game mechanics: Push your luck, escalating bids, player challenges, card drawing, risk management, scoring and digital quiz interaction.
- Educational theme: Household water conservation and responsible consumption.
- Physical edition: 2,500 copies produced by 2016.
- Game duration: A standard playing time has not been independently verified.
- Languages: The instruction sheet was produced in English, Italian, German, Spanish and Valencian.
- Digital companion: Drop!TheQuestion, an Android application using QR codes and water-related questions.
Final physical components (2016)
- 40 numbered positive Lily Cards.
- 10 negative Monster Cards.
- 50 point markers.
- One printed instruction sheet.
- A cardboard game box.
Main game mechanics
- Bidding: A player declares how many positive cards can be revealed without drawing a Monster Card.
- Escalation: The next player may accept the challenge or increase the declared number.
- Player challenge: When a declaration is challenged, the active player must attempt the stated card draw.
- Risk-taking: Higher bids provide an opportunity to obtain more points but increase the risk of drawing a negative card.
- Positive scoring: Successfully revealed Lily Cards provide points according to their numerical values.
- Distinct-value scoring: The original rules score each different numerical value only once within a successful draw.
- Penalty cards: Drawing a Monster Card results in a negative outcome, and the player keeps the card.
- Redistribution: Following an unsuccessful challenge, other participants may receive points from the positive cards revealed.
- Digital recovery: Monster Cards can be scanned using the companion application to activate a water-related quiz and potentially recover points.
- Score comparison: Players compare their final scores to determine the winner.
Rules and version distinction
The game’s original D4.1 prototype used 60 cards, including 45 positive cards and 15 Monster Cards. Its published rules describe ending the game after eight Monster Cards have been drawn or once a predefined score threshold has been reached.
The final D4.4 edition reduced the deck to 50 cards, including 40 positive and 10 negative cards.
Therefore, the original prototype’s precise ending conditions should not automatically be attributed to the final printed edition.
Educational value of the physical components
The cards depict examples of responsible and wasteful water consumption.
However, the numerical bidding and risk-taking mechanism primarily provides entertainment. Players do not need to answer knowledge questions to win the physical game.
Its principal educational contribution is to introduce water-related imagery and stimulate interest in the digital learning activities.
2. Drop!TheQuestion – Digital Companion
Drop!TheQuestion is a complementary mobile trivia game designed to extend the physical game.
Players can scan a QR code associated with a Monster Card and answer questions about water consumption, water resources and sustainable behaviour.
Correct answers can improve the outcome of the physical game and generate points connected with the SmartH2O consumer portal.
The application can also be used independently of the physical cards.
Documented features
- QR-code interaction with physical Monster Cards.
- Multiple-choice questions about water and conservation.
- Integration with the SmartH2O reward system.
- Standalone mobile quiz mode.
- Progressive question difficulty.
- Usage monitoring for researchers and platform managers.
- A final question bank of 474 questions documented in September 2016.
The project subsequently used feedback on question difficulty to refine the application’s content.
3. SmartH2O Consumer Portal – Complementary Gamification Platform
The broader SmartH2O platform provided household water consumption feedback, conservation recommendations, personal goals, points, badges, leaderboards and physical rewards.
The DROP! game was offered as a reward for participation in selected platform activities.
The physical cards, mobile game and consumer portal formed an interconnected engagement system.
Game availability
The final physical game was produced and distributed to pilot households and used in educational and promotional activities.
However, no currently operational public ordering service or complete free print-and-play kit has been identified.
The official D4.4 deliverable remains available through CORDIS and includes photographs of the game and a reproduction of the instruction sheet.
D4.4 – Final Physical Game and Digital Extension (PDF)
D4.1 – Original Game Design and Rules (PDF)
Game approach
The appropriate classification is Custom-Designed Educational Games, with a hybrid physical-digital implementation.
5. BGBL Methodology
SmartH2O adopted a multichannel gamification and Game-Based Learning approach designed to encourage sustainable household water consumption.
The methodology combined a physical card game, digital quiz activities, water consumption monitoring and a reward system within a single engagement programme.
The physical game was intended to attract participants, particularly children and families, while the digital components provided more explicit information about water-saving behaviour.
Pedagogical and behavioural foundations
- Game-Based Learning: Physical gameplay provides an entertaining introduction to water conservation themes.
- Persuasive game design: Game experiences are used to increase motivation to engage with sustainability content.
- Hybrid learning: QR codes connect physical cards with digital activities.
- Family learning: The card game provides an opportunity for intergenerational interaction.
- Knowledge reinforcement: Digital questions introduce factual information about water use and conservation.
- Behavioural feedback: Smart metering provides information about actual household consumption.
- Goal setting: The consumer portal allows households to establish water-saving targets.
- Gamification: Points, achievements and rewards encourage continued participation.
Engagement sequence
- Initial participation: A household engages with the SmartH2O programme and consumer portal.
- Physical reward: Participants may obtain DROP! as a reward for using the platform.
- Family gameplay: Players use Lily and Monster Cards in a risk-taking and bidding game.
- Digital connection: Monster Cards can activate mobile questions through QR-code scanning.
- Knowledge activity: Participants answer questions about sustainable water consumption.
- Portal engagement: Digital achievements may contribute to the broader platform’s points and reward system.
- Everyday application: Households can consult consumption data and water-saving recommendations.
Game mechanics and educational content
DROP! separates entertainment and explicit knowledge acquisition to a significant extent.
The physical card game uses risk, bidding and social interaction to encourage play. Its illustrations communicate positive and negative water-use practices, but the rules do not require players to understand these practices.
The mobile quiz introduces factual questions and links participation with the wider sustainability programme.
This distinction is essential when analysing the educational integration of the game.
Facilitation
The game was designed for informal family use without a required professional facilitator.
However, documented school activities were supported by researchers who explained the rules and connected the game with water conservation education.
The project also gathered feedback from families, teachers and children to refine the experience.
Debriefing and reflection
Informal conversation about water-saving practices was an intended benefit of family gameplay.
Nevertheless, a standardised post-game debriefing protocol has not been identified.
For educational reuse, teachers could extend gameplay by discussing the situations represented on the cards, comparing responsible and wasteful behaviours, and connecting the quiz questions with everyday household decisions.
These suggestions are possible educational applications rather than independently verified elements of the original rules.
Methodological transferability
SmartH2O provides a distinctive example of using a simple physical card game as the starting point for a wider educational and behavioural engagement programme.
The model may inform other sustainability initiatives combining family games with digital educational content.
However, independent reproduction of the complete intervention requires access to the physical game materials, functioning digital services and appropriate reuse permissions.
6. Implementation & Evaluation
SmartH2O was implemented between April 2014 and March 2017 as a collaborative research project funded by the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme.
The project combined smart water metering, household consumption feedback, behavioural research, digital gamification and an original physical card game designed to encourage engagement with water conservation.
Participating organisations
The consortium was coordinated by SUPSI (Switzerland) and included research, technological and utility partners from Switzerland, Spain, Italy, Germany, Romania and the United Kingdom.
Relevant contributors to the game and its implementation included Politecnico di Milano, the European Institute for Participatory Media, Moonsubmarine, Società Elettrica Sopracenerina (SES), EMIVASA and other SmartH2O partners.
Game development and production
- 2014 – Initial development: The consortium documented the DROP! game concept, push-your-luck mechanics, card design, digital integration and initial user testing in deliverable D4.1.
- Family testing: A prototype was tested with a family and children of different ages to examine playability, accessibility and the digital extension.
- School consultation: Teachers and students in Brescia, Italy, contributed feedback about educational games, game preferences and the suitability of water conservation activities for classroom learning.
- 2015–2016 – Refinement: The game and digital components were revised following user feedback and implementation requirements.
- 2016 – Final physical production: Moonsubmarine produced 2,500 boxed copies of DROP!.
- 2016–2017 – Pilot distribution: Copies were used in water utility engagement programmes in Switzerland and Spain.
- 2017 – Final project assessment: The consortium published evaluation reports covering platform engagement, digital game use, participant perceptions and water consumption outcomes.
- Post-project dissemination: DROP! continued to be demonstrated during educational and scientific outreach events.
Distribution of the physical game
Deliverable D4.4 records the production and allocation of 2,500 boxed copies:
- 500 copies: Delivered to SES for use as rewards and promotional materials in the Swiss Tegna pilot.
- 1,500 copies: Delivered to EMIVASA for rewards and promotional activities in the Valencia pilot.
- 500 remaining copies: Retained for testing and dissemination, including activities with pilot schools, the SmartH2O Summer School and public events.
These figures document copies produced and allocated. They should not be interpreted as the number of households that actually played the physical game.
Preliminary family evaluation
The initial D4.1 report describes a prototype test with a family including children aged eight and thirteen, together with some of their friends.
The group received the physical game and the digital companion for a weekend.
Feedback indicated that the game was generally playable, but identified several issues:
- Some rules concerning bidding and redistribution of points required clarification.
- Older children considered the card mechanics relatively simple.
- Younger participants did not always understand the meaning of the water-related illustrations.
- The relationship between the numerical values of the cards and the environmental value of the represented actions was unclear.
- Some digital quiz questions were considered too difficult or formal for children.
These findings provided useful formative information about the balance between entertainment, accessibility and educational content.
Swiss digital pilot – 2016
Deliverable D4.4 reports an initial evaluation of Drop!TheQuestion in the Swiss pilot.
The data included:
- 54 users of the digital game.
- 658 recorded digital play sessions.
- 573 sessions using the standalone mode.
- 85 sessions using the physical-card scanning mode.
- 8,948 answers submitted to quiz questions.
- Approximately 51% correct answers on average.
The relatively low correct-answer rate led developers to reconsider the difficulty of the educational questions and introduce a more progressive selection system.
The question bank was also expanded to 474 questions in the 2016 release.
Preliminary acceptance questionnaire
The Swiss pilot included a questionnaire based on the Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT).
Four respondents who had used DROP! provided game-specific feedback.
Most responses were favourable regarding usability, enjoyment and the perceived interest of learning about water conservation.
However, the sample was too small to support general conclusions.
Spanish final evaluation – 2017
Deliverable D7.3, Final Overall Validation and Impact Report, provides additional evidence from the Spanish pilot.
Twelve users of Drop!TheQuestion who also used the SmartH2O consumer portal completed a questionnaire.
Of these, four reported playing the physical game together with the mobile application.
The results indicated generally favourable opinions about the game’s ease of use and its ability to make water conservation more interesting.
Some respondents nevertheless considered the quiz questions difficult, indicating the need for better adaptation to different ages and knowledge levels.
The four respondents who used both components generally found the QR-code interaction easy, and three reported positive experiences of playing the physical game with the application.
These results should be interpreted as preliminary usability and acceptance findings rather than evidence of educational effectiveness.
School implementation and educational dissemination
Project reporting documents activities involving schools and teachers in Italy.
The final evaluation includes feedback from teachers at Albavilla secondary school, who described positive student participation and considered the activity relevant to environmental sustainability education.
After the formal end of SmartH2O, researchers from Politecnico di Milano and the game’s designer organised another educational activity at MEETmeTONIGHT, the European Researchers’ Night event in Como, on 29 September 2017.
Students from the G. Parini lower secondary school used DROP! under researcher guidance to explore responsible water consumption.
Project-wide water conservation outcomes
CORDIS and institutional reporting describe water consumption reductions of approximately 20% among participating users in Spain and 10% in Switzerland, compared with relevant non-participating groups or reference consumption patterns.
These results refer to the broader SmartH2O intervention involving smart meters, consumption feedback, digital recommendations, goals, incentives and gamification.
They must not be attributed specifically to the DROP! physical card game.
Later scientific research examined the relationship between smart meter feedback, digital engagement and household water consumption.
This research provides evidence about the wider platform, but does not isolate the educational or behavioural contribution of the physical game.
Evaluation limitations
- No isolated physical-game effect: Water savings cannot be causally attributed to DROP!.
- Small game-specific samples: Only a few respondents were identified as having used both the physical and digital components in the reported questionnaires.
- Digital versus physical exposure: Most recorded digital sessions occurred independently of card scanning.
- No validated knowledge pretest-posttest: Improvements in water conservation knowledge attributable to playing the cards were not established.
- No controlled comparison: The physical card game was not independently evaluated against an equivalent non-game educational activity.
- Limited evidence of family learning: The number of households actively using the physical game and the educational outcomes of their interactions were not established.
- Question difficulty: Participants identified problems with the complexity and suitability of some quiz questions.
- Digital access: Hybrid gameplay depends on access to compatible devices and functioning services.
- Long-term educational effects: Retention of knowledge and sustained behaviour change attributable to the card game remain unverified.
Overall evaluation status
SmartH2O provides strong evidence that an original physical educational card game was developed, produced and distributed at scale.
The programme also generated detailed usage data and preliminary acceptance evaluations for its digital companion.
Its strongest educational evidence concerns engagement and usability within a hybrid physical-digital learning environment.
The contribution of the physical card game to measurable learning gains or actual household water savings has not been independently established.
7. Educational Resources
SmartH2O developed a collection of physical and digital resources intended to encourage awareness of domestic water consumption and promote more sustainable household behaviour.
Its principal Board Game-Based Learning resource is DROP!, an original physical card game accompanied by a mobile trivia application called Drop!TheQuestion.
The project’s public deliverables provide detailed documentation of the game design, production, pilot testing and evaluation. However, the original physical game and digital application are not currently available through a verified public distribution channel.
1. DROP! – Physical Educational Card Game
DROP! is an original family-oriented card game designed around a push-your-luck mechanism.
Players attempt to collect positive cards representing Lily, a character who promotes responsible water use, while avoiding negative Monster Cards associated with wasting water.
The final physical edition contains:
- 40 numbered positive Lily Cards.
- 10 negative Monster Cards.
- 50 point markers.
- One instruction sheet.
- A printed game box.
The project produced 2,500 physical copies for distribution and dissemination.
Instructions were prepared in English, Italian, German, Spanish and Valencian.
The game can be played as a physical card game, while its educational extension allows players to transform negative cards into positive results through water-conservation questions answered on a smartphone or tablet.
Availability: Physical production and distribution are documented, but a current commercial distributor or complete public print-and-play package has not been identified.
2. SmartH2O D4.1 – First Social Game and Implicit User Information Techniques
Deliverable D4.1, published in December 2014, is the most detailed accessible description of the original DROP! game concept.
It includes:
- The rationale for selecting push-your-luck mechanics.
- The characters Lily and the water-wasting monster.
- Gameplay rules and scoring procedures for the initial prototype.
- Early game illustrations and component descriptions.
- The relationship between the physical game and mobile applications.
- Preliminary testing with children and parents.
- Initial educational questions for Drop!TheQuestion.
The original prototype included 45 positive and 15 negative cards, for a total of 60 cards. This configuration was subsequently revised in the final physical edition.
The original rules are useful for understanding the development of the game but should not automatically be treated as the definitive rules of the final 50-card edition.
SmartH2O D4.1 – First Social Game and Game Design Documentation (PDF)
3. SmartH2O D4.4 – Final Social Game and Implicit User Information Techniques
Deliverable D4.4 documents the final version of the physical DROP! game and its accompanying digital infrastructure.
The report confirms the production of 2,500 copies and identifies the physical components of the final edition.
It also documents the implementation of Drop!TheQuestion, its connection with the SmartH2O Consumer Portal and the evaluation of user engagement.
The document includes photographs of the final game and an illustration of the printed instruction sheet.
SmartH2O D4.4 – Final Social Game, Components and User Evaluation (PDF)
Availability: The report remains indexed by CORDIS, but direct retrieval of the approximately 13 MB PDF was unsuccessful during this review. Its indexed contents confirm the game’s final production details.
4. Drop!TheQuestion – Mobile Educational Trivia Game
Drop!TheQuestion is the digital companion to the physical card game.
Players can scan QR codes printed on Monster Cards to access questions about water conservation.
Correct answers allow negative card outcomes to be converted into positive results and can also generate rewards within the SmartH2O Consumer Portal.
The application was designed to operate both alongside the physical game and as a separate mobile learning activity.
Its educational purpose is more explicit than that of the physical card mechanics, because answering water-related questions requires engagement with factual content.
Availability: Historical application development and use are documented in D4.4 and D7.3. A currently functional version suitable for installation and use in 2026 has not been verified.
SmartH2O – Official Project Reporting and Digital Game Deliverables
5. SmartH2O D7.3 – Final Overall Validation and Impact Report
The final evaluation report provides important evidence concerning the project’s digital platform, water-saving interventions and the use of Drop!TheQuestion.
The report includes:
- Questionnaire results for users of the digital game.
- Information about the relationship between the app and the physical cards.
- Assessment of perceived usability, enjoyment and difficulty.
- Findings from school activities.
- Analysis of participation in the SmartH2O platform.
- Evaluation of water-consumption behaviour across the pilot interventions.
- Limitations concerning adoption and sustained engagement.
In the game-specific questionnaire, twelve Spanish users of Drop!TheQuestion responded, including four who had also played with the physical cards.
These results provide preliminary evidence of user acceptance but do not establish independent learning gains attributable to the physical game.
SmartH2O D7.3 – Final Overall Validation and Impact Report (PDF)
6. DROP and FUNERGY – Scientific Conference Publication
Albertarelli, S., Fraternali, P., Novak, J., Rizzoli, A. E., & Rottondi, C. (2017). DROP and FUNERGY: Two gamified learning projects for water and energy conservation. Proceedings of the 11th European Conference on Games Based Learning (ECGBL 2017), 935–938.
This publication describes DROP! as a physical game intended to encourage participation in the wider SmartH2O educational and behavioural change platform.
It also introduces the subsequent adaptation of the approach to energy conservation through the enCOMPASS project and its FUNERGY game concept.
DROP and FUNERGY – Institutional Scientific Publication Record
7. A Survey on the Design of Gamified Systems for Energy and Water Sustainability
Albertarelli, S., Fraternali, P., Herrera, S., Melenhorst, M., Novak, J., Pasini, C., Rizzoli, A. E., & Rottondi, C. (2018). A survey on the design of gamified systems for energy and water sustainability. Games, 9(3), 38.
This open-access scientific article describes DROP! and Drop!TheQuestion and places them within the broader research on gamified systems and behaviour change.
It explains why the designers selected a simple family-oriented push-your-luck mechanism and how QR-based questions connected physical gameplay with water-saving information.
A Survey on the Design of Gamified Systems for Energy and Water Sustainability – Games (2018)
8. SmartH2O – Institutional Research and Behavioural Change Resources
Politecnico di Milano maintains a project overview describing the smart-meter infrastructure, gamified platform, feedback systems and behavioural change activities implemented in Switzerland and Spain.
The page also links to a video entitled Drop – Giocare con l’acqua.
The resource is useful for understanding how the physical card game formed part of a wider programme of household water-conservation engagement.
Politecnico di Milano – SmartH2O Research Overview and Educational Media
9. Long-Term Water Conservation Research
Subsequent scientific research examined the relationship between smart-meter feedback, digital user engagement and water conservation.
This research is valuable for understanding the wider impact of SmartH2O and the challenges of sustained behaviour change.
However, its findings should not be presented as evidence of the independent effectiveness of the DROP! card game.
10. European Commission – SmartH2O Project Results
CORDIS provides the official funding record, project reporting and information about the project’s deployment.
The European Commission’s Results in Brief article explicitly confirms that a physical game with a digital extension was developed and distributed to households in Spain and Switzerland.
SmartH2O – ICT Solutions to Enhance Urban Water Management
SmartH2O – Official CORDIS Project Record
Resource accessibility and licensing
The original project website is no longer available as a conventional active educational platform.
However, the European Commission continues to preserve public technical deliverables, and institutional research websites provide additional documentation and scientific publications.
The D4.1 report identifies a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 licence for the document. This should not automatically be interpreted as permission to reproduce the final commercial-quality cards, illustrations, software or game box.
A complete print-ready package for the final DROP! edition and current operational access to Drop!TheQuestion have not been independently established.
Replicability
The publicly available reports provide sufficient information to study the original game mechanics, educational rationale and development process.
Independent recreation of the final integrated physical-digital experience would require the complete card files, clarification of reproduction rights and a functional or reconstructed digital question system.
8. Ludus Magnus Methodological Insight
SmartH2O is a valuable case for the European Board Game-Based Learning Observatory because it demonstrates how an original physical card game can be integrated into a broader digital engagement and behavioural change programme.
The project’s principal tabletop contribution is DROP!, a push-your-luck card game designed to attract families and encourage interaction with water-conservation resources.
Its distinctive methodological feature is the deliberate separation between the motivational function of the physical game and the more explicit educational function of its mobile trivia extension.
Methodological strengths
- Original physical game: DROP! was developed as a complete card game with documented mechanics, components and rules.
- Large-scale physical production: The project manufactured 2,500 boxed copies, demonstrating completion beyond the prototype stage.
- Established game mechanism: The use of push-your-luck gameplay creates uncertainty, tension and accessible interaction.
- Family-oriented design: The game encourages participation by children and adults in a shared household activity.
- Simple physical interactions: Players can engage with the card game without needing specialist knowledge about water conservation.
- Hybrid physical-digital architecture: QR codes connect the physical cards with mobile educational questions.
- Educational recovery mechanism: Players can use correct answers to transform negative card outcomes into more favourable results.
- Connection with everyday behaviour: The theme of responsible and wasteful water use links gameplay with familiar household activities.
- Integration with a wider platform: Correct answers in the mobile game contribute points to SmartH2O’s gamified Consumer Portal.
- Participatory prototype testing: Early evaluation involved children, parents and school stakeholders.
- Iterative refinement: The final physical edition differed from the initial prototype, showing development beyond the original concept.
- Multilingual dissemination: The final instructions were prepared in five languages.
- Documented implementation: Distribution and educational activities were reported in Spain and Switzerland.
- Dedicated user evaluation: The final project report examined the usability, enjoyment and perceived educational relevance of Drop!TheQuestion.
- Scientific dissemination: Peer-reviewed publications explain the game’s design and its relationship with sustainability-oriented gamification.
Methodological limitations and considerations
- Weak mechanical integration of factual learning: Winning the physical card game does not require knowledge about water conservation.
- Educational content primarily located outside the physical game: Correct answers become relevant through the mobile extension rather than through the principal card-drawing mechanic.
- Dependence on digital functionality: The complete intended experience depends on QR scanning and access to the mobile question system.
- Very small combined-game evaluation: Only four respondents in the final Spanish game questionnaire had used both the physical cards and the mobile extension.
- No independently demonstrated learning gains: The evaluation does not establish improvements in water-conservation knowledge through validated pretest-posttest measures.
- Behavioural attribution: Reported household water savings concern the complete SmartH2O intervention, not the individual contribution of DROP!.
- Question difficulty: Participants reported that mobile trivia questions became too difficult, particularly after repeated use.
- Limited question pool: The project identified the need for additional questions and age-appropriate difficulty levels.
- Age differences: Early testing suggested that the card mechanics and illustrations were more attractive to younger children than to teenagers.
- Potential ambiguity of the visual metaphor: Younger participants did not always understand the significance of the sustainable and wasteful behaviours represented on cards.
- Limited evidence of repeated physical play: Production and distribution figures do not establish how frequently recipients played the game.
- Possible engagement barriers: The physical-to-digital transition introduces additional steps that may discourage participation.
- Unverified current availability: The original game and application are not supported by a confirmed operational public distribution channel in 2026.
- Licensing uncertainty: Public access to research reports does not necessarily permit reproduction of the physical game or software.
Relationship between mechanics and educational objectives
DROP! provides a particularly useful example of the difference between a game being educational through its mechanics and a game being connected with educational content.
In the physical card game, players make decisions about risk, challenge other players and attempt to obtain favourable scores.
These decisions do not require the application of water-conservation knowledge.
The illustrations of Lily and the monster provide a thematic metaphor, associating responsible consumption with positive outcomes and waste with negative outcomes.
However, the numerical and strategic decisions are primarily governed by probability and risk-taking rather than by sustainability principles.
The educational questions are introduced through Drop!TheQuestion, allowing factual knowledge to influence the conversion of negative card results into positive outcomes.
This creates an educational connection between physical and digital gameplay, but it also demonstrates that the central learning mechanism is located partly outside the physical game.
The educational role of push-your-luck
Push-your-luck games generate engagement by asking players to decide how much risk they are willing to accept.
In DROP!, this provides an accessible mechanism for generating excitement and interaction across a mixed-age group.
However, the relationship between taking a risk in a card game and conserving water in everyday life is indirect.
Consequently, the game’s educational value should not be attributed automatically to its risk-taking mechanic.
Instead, the intended contribution is to attract users, create opportunities for conversation and lead participants towards more explicit educational content.
The physical game as a gateway to learning
The project’s scientific publications explicitly present DROP! as an enjoyable route into the wider SmartH2O programme.
This approach differs from educational games in which the learning objective is embedded directly in the strategic decisions required to win.
In SmartH2O, the physical game operates mainly as a motivational gateway, while the application and digital platform provide additional knowledge, feedback and behaviour-change incentives.
This separation may be useful when the intended audience is unlikely to engage initially with conventional educational materials.
However, it also creates the risk that users enjoy the game without progressing towards the intended learning activities.
Feedback from children and families
The early prototype evaluation identified several design issues that are particularly relevant to educational game development.
An adult participant considered the basic gameplay understandable but identified ambiguities in certain rules.
A teenage participant found the mechanics relatively simple and suggested the addition of more varied cards.
A younger participant had difficulty interpreting the environmental meaning of certain illustrations and considered the mobile questions insufficiently adapted to children.
These findings suggest that thematic design, gameplay complexity and educational question difficulty require separate evaluation.
They also illustrate the value of testing games with the actual intended audience before large-scale production.
Evidence of user engagement
The final evaluation reported favourable reactions to Drop!TheQuestion among twelve surveyed users.
However, only four had combined the application with the physical card game.
All four considered QR scanning relatively easy, and three expressed favourable views about playing the hybrid version.
Although encouraging, these results are insufficient to make reliable generalisations about the usability or educational effectiveness of the combined game.
Distinguishing game effects from programme effects
SmartH2O reported reductions in water consumption associated with its wider interventions in Valencia and Switzerland.
However, those interventions combined smart meters, consumption visualisation, personalised feedback, digital incentives, educational resources and other engagement mechanisms.
The available evidence does not allow the contribution of the DROP! physical card game to be isolated.
Therefore, the reported water savings should not be presented as an educational or behavioural effect demonstrated for DROP! itself.
This distinction is especially important for the Observatory when comparing European projects that report impressive programme-level outcomes without evaluating their board-game components separately.
Physical-digital integration and long-term sustainability
The dependence on a digital extension creates both opportunities and limitations.
The QR-based system allows a physical game to be connected with changing educational content, user profiles and gamified digital rewards.
At the same time, the durability of the complete educational experience depends on continued software maintenance, platform compatibility and access to online services.
When these services are no longer operational, the physical card game may remain playable, but the intended educational functionality becomes partially inaccessible.
For European projects, this creates a need to plan for long-term preservation of both physical and digital educational resources.
Implications for future BGBL initiatives
- Distinguish between games designed to teach through their mechanics and games designed primarily to attract users towards educational content.
- Use engaging physical mechanics as an entry point when the intended audience has limited initial interest in the subject.
- Ensure that the educational significance of game illustrations is understandable to younger players.
- Test gameplay complexity separately for children, teenagers and adults.
- Adapt educational question difficulty to the age and prior knowledge of participants.
- Provide sufficient variety in digital question pools to support repeated play.
- Evaluate the physical game, digital extension and complete combined experience separately.
- Measure learning outcomes independently of enjoyment and application usability.
- Avoid attributing programme-wide environmental outcomes to an individual game without appropriate evidence.
- Document how physical components and digital services depend on one another.
- Plan for offline alternatives when long-term software availability cannot be guaranteed.
- Preserve printable components, rules, question banks and licensing information for future educational reuse.
Overall assessment
SmartH2O provides a well-documented example of an original physical card game integrated into a wider sustainability-oriented digital engagement programme.
Its principal strengths are the completion and production of 2,500 physical copies, accessible family-oriented mechanics, hybrid QR-based educational activities, multilingual dissemination and detailed technical reporting.
Its main limitations are the indirect relationship between physical gameplay and water-conservation learning, the small sample evaluating the combined physical-digital experience, and the absence of independently demonstrated learning or behavioural effects attributable to the card game alone.
For the European BGBL Observatory, SmartH2O is particularly valuable as a case study of hybrid tabletop learning, games as motivational gateways, the challenges of isolating educational outcomes and the long-term sustainability of digitally connected physical games.
