
The Human-Tech Nexus – Building a Safe Haven to Cope with Climate Extremes
The HuT developed Safe Haven, a family of physical educational board games simulating municipal decisions about climate-related disaster risks. Players manage limited budgets, select mitigation measures and respond to uncertain events affecting hazard, exposure and vulnerability. Developed for secondary school students and other audiences, the games were used with over 200 participants across three European countries. Complete print-and-play packages for several variants are publicly available on Zenodo.
1. Project Overview
- Funding programme
- Horizon Europe – Cluster 3: Civil Security for Society
- Project reference
- 101073957
- Period
- 2022–2026
- Coordinating organisation
- Università degli Studi di Salerno (Italy)
- Participating countries
- 22 beneficiaries listed by CORDIS, including the coordinator; additional collaborating organisations
- Official project website
- Visit official website
2. Learning Objectives
The HuT (The Human-Tech Nexus – Building a Safe Haven to Cope with Climate Extremes) aimed to improve disaster risk reduction and climate resilience by integrating scientific knowledge, technological innovations, governance solutions and community participation.
The project addressed climate-related hazards including floods, landslides, heatwaves, wildfires, droughts and storms through a network of ten European demonstrators.
Within Work Package 3, Governance and Policy, the consortium developed Safe Haven, a family of original physical educational board games designed to improve understanding of disaster risk through municipal decision-making simulations.
Specific learning objectives
- Disaster risk literacy: Understand the factors contributing to disaster risk and the possibilities for reducing them.
- Hazard, exposure and vulnerability: Recognise the three components of risk and how they interact.
- Quantitative risk reasoning: Understand the simplified relationship Risk = Hazard × Exposure × Vulnerability.
- Probability: Recognise that risk-related events are uncertain and that disaster probabilities cannot necessarily be eliminated.
- Risk acceptability: Explore why municipalities establish thresholds for acceptable or tolerable risk.
- Preventive planning: Identify measures that may reduce the consequences of climate-related hazards.
- Risk mitigation: Compare measures targeting hazard, exposure or vulnerability.
- Financial literacy: Understand the implications of limited public budgets when planning risk reduction.
- Maintenance planning: Recognise that some preventive measures require continued investment after initial implementation.
- Cost-benefit reasoning: Consider the relationship between prevention expenditure, expected risk reduction and potential consequences of disasters.
- Strategic decision-making: Select and combine measures under conditions of limited resources and uncertainty.
- Climate change adaptation: Explore how changing climatic conditions may influence future disaster risk.
- Urbanisation and development: Examine how changes in exposure and vulnerability can increase risk.
- Risk uncertainty: Recognise that the actual effectiveness of risk reduction measures may be uncertain.
- Short- and long-term planning: Experience the consequences of decisions across successive simulated years.
- Trade-off analysis: Balance immediate costs with the benefits of future risk reduction.
- Local risk management: Explore how municipal circumstances influence the selection of appropriate measures.
- Systems thinking: Understand relationships among environmental hazards, infrastructure, populations, public investment and disaster consequences.
- Scientific reasoning: Apply simplified probabilistic and quantitative concepts in practical decision-making.
- Collaborative learning: Discuss alternative strategies when the game is played in teams or facilitated groups.
- Community preparedness: Encourage awareness of the importance of preventive decisions before disasters occur.
Three core educational concepts
The official project methodology identifies three principles underlying the design of Safe Haven:
- Risk has three interacting components: Hazard, exposure and vulnerability.
- Risk is probabilistic: The probability of a disaster is uncertain and cannot always be reduced to zero.
- Risk reduction requires appropriate measures: Different interventions influence different components and are not equally suitable for every hazard.
Additional objectives of the multi-hazard version
The multi-hazard version extends these learning objectives to interactions between several hazards, differences between territories and the effects of alternative future socioeconomic pathways.
Its educational focus includes compound disaster events, unequal resources, changing climate-related risks and the challenges of simultaneously managing several threats.
Educational scope
Safe Haven was developed primarily for secondary school students, but its practical implementation also included university audiences, citizens and disaster risk professionals.
The project documents use and favourable qualitative feedback. Independently validated improvements in knowledge, risk perception or professional competence have not been established by the sources reviewed.
3. Target Groups
4. Board Games Used or Developed
The HuT developed Safe Haven, an original family of physical educational board games addressing the management of climate-related disaster risks.
The games simulate decisions made by municipal authorities attempting to keep the risk of natural hazards below an acceptable threshold while operating with limited financial resources.
The original system was developed by Laurens J. N. Oostwegel, Maria Vittoria Gargiulo, Guido Rianna and Michele Calvello, with additional research contributions to specific variants.
1. Safe Haven – Landslides
Safe Haven – Landslides is the original published physical version, focusing on the management of landslide risk.
Players act as municipal decision-makers responsible for protecting a fictional municipality over successive simulated years.
They use resources to implement and maintain measures that reduce hazard, exposure or vulnerability.
Random events and changing scenarios affect the municipality’s risk level, requiring players to adapt their decisions.
Verified characteristics
- Game type: Original educational board and card game.
- Game format: Physical boards, cards, 12-sided dice, tokens, scorecards and scenario materials.
- Game approach: Individual team decision-making within a simulated municipal risk management environment.
- Player organisation: Up to six teams in the physical version; four teams are recommended for better playability.
- Playing time: A standard duration has not been independently verified.
- Educational audience: High-school students, educators, interested adults and disaster risk professionals.
- First public game release: 21 September 2025.
- Open resources: Complete physical game files and do-it-yourself instructions published on Zenodo.
Core game components
- Physical game board.
- Risk Reduction Cards.
- Chance Cards.
- Scenario Cards and descriptions.
- Scorecards.
- Dice representing hazard, exposure and vulnerability.
- Game rules.
- Setup instructions.
- Do-it-yourself production instructions.
- A spreadsheet containing card values and supporting data.
Risk model
The game represents disaster risk through three factors:
Risk = Hazard × Exposure × Vulnerability.
Players must understand that a municipality can reduce its risk by addressing different factors, not only by attempting to prevent the physical hazard itself.
The basic risk situation is established using dice, and participants can modify it through the preventive measures selected during gameplay.
Risk Reduction Cards
Risk Reduction Cards represent possible interventions targeting the three risk components.
Each category contains different levels of effectiveness. The project documentation explains that some measures are correctly implemented and provide effective risk reduction, some are only moderately effective, and some may fail because of design or implementation mistakes.
Players must consider acquisition and maintenance costs and the uncertainty surrounding actual effectiveness.
Chance Cards
Chance Cards introduce unexpected events that may increase or decrease risk.
For example, landslide scenarios may include earthquakes or other events that affect slope stability.
Game Scenarios
Three overall scenarios represent different levels of difficulty.
These scenarios introduce changing environmental, social or economic conditions over successive rounds.
Such changes may include increasing vulnerability because of ageing infrastructure, altered climatic conditions or reductions in public funding.
Main game mechanics
- Risk assessment through the combination of hazard, exposure and vulnerability.
- Dice-based uncertainty and probability.
- Budget allocation.
- Selection and purchase of risk reduction measures.
- Maintenance of previously implemented interventions.
- Hidden or uncertain measure effectiveness.
- Risk recalculation.
- Chance events.
- Changing scenarios across successive years.
- Management of acceptable risk thresholds.
- Strategic survival across repeated rounds.
Three phases per round
- Dice phase: The basic risk situation is established using hazard, exposure and vulnerability dice.
- Risk reduction phase: Players select and maintain preventive measures within their available budgets.
- Chance phase: Unexpected events may modify the resulting risk conditions.
The game uses twelve-sided dice. The methodology describes nine dice representing three risk components across different probability distributions.
Educational integration
The educational concepts are incorporated into the central actions of gameplay. Players cannot manage the municipality effectively without considering the relationship between risk factors, intervention effectiveness, budget constraints and uncertain events.
Safe Haven – Landslides: Complete Board Game, Cards, Rules and Printable Files
2. Safe Haven – Floods
Safe Haven – Floods adapts the same underlying game system to flood risk management.
The game retains the structure of dice-based risk assessment, preventive measures, chance events and changing scenarios.
However, its cards represent interventions and circumstances relevant to flooding.
Examples include flood protection infrastructure, drainage systems and measures that influence exposure or vulnerability.
The project documentation identifies polders as an example of a measure specific to flood hazard management.
Some scenario changes also reflect the deterioration of drainage systems and flood defences over time.
Publication: 13 January 2026.
Availability: Complete board, card files, rules, scenarios, scorecards and DIY production instructions are publicly available.
Safe Haven – Floods: Complete Print-and-Play Package
3. Safe Haven – Heatwaves
Safe Haven – Heatwaves adapts the same educational mechanics to heatwave risk management.
The game explores how municipalities may reduce risks associated with extreme heat through measures targeting hazard, exposure and vulnerability.
Its development involved a research team from the Universitat Politècnica de València.
The project manual identifies a Spanish-language version, while the Zenodo record uses English in its language metadata. The language of every individual file has not been independently checked.
Publication: 25 March 2026.
Availability: Publicly available board, cards, rules, setup instructions, scenarios, scorecards and DIY materials.
Safe Haven – Heatwaves: Complete Print-and-Play Package
4. Safe Haven – Wildfires
The official D3.5 manual identifies a fourth single-hazard variant covering wildfires, with English and Italian versions.
It uses the same basic game structure as the preceding variants while adapting the preventive measures and event cards to wildfire risk.
However, a specific downloadable repository containing the complete Wildfires materials could not be independently located during this review.
Its existence is supported by the project manual, but individual resource accessibility remains unverified.
5. Safe Haven – Multi-hazard
The project also developed a multi-hazard design intended to explore the simultaneous management of several climate-related threats.
This version introduces additional complexity while retaining the central principles of the single-hazard games.
Players manage territories with different starting risk levels, acceptable risk thresholds and budgets.
Hazards represented
- Landslides.
- Floods.
- Wildfires.
- Droughts.
Additional mechanisms
- Use-case cards representing different territories.
- Different initial hazard, exposure and vulnerability levels.
- Different annual budgets and acceptable risk thresholds.
- Preventive measures targeting one or several hazards.
- Higher costs associated with some multi-hazard interventions.
- Compound events affecting several hazards.
- Global scenarios based on Shared Socioeconomic Pathways.
- Local scenario changes affecting individual territories.
- Changing probabilities of hazardous events as the game progresses.
The project manual provides a detailed description of the multi-hazard design, including card structures and illustrative scenarios.
However, a separate final print-and-play release for the complete multi-hazard version has not been independently verified.
6. Digital Companion
Safe Haven also has a digital version developed using the Godot game engine.
The official manual describes individual and multiplayer modes.
The online version supports single-player games and larger groups than the physical edition, which is constrained by the number of available cards.
It reproduces the educational framework of the tabletop game but should be classified as a complementary digital resource rather than as an additional physical board game.
The manual identifies a public web deployment and describes open-source code and deployment documentation. The current operational status of the web application has not been independently confirmed.
Safe Haven – Online Game (Availability Not Verified)
Overall game approach
The appropriate classification is Custom-Designed Educational Games.
The different Safe Haven editions form a related family of original physical games that adapt a common set of mechanics to specific climate-related hazards.
5. BGBL Methodology
The Board Game-Based Learning methodology of The HuT is centred on Safe Haven, an original family of physical educational board games designed to develop disaster risk awareness and understanding of climate-related hazards.
The games combine simulation-based learning, role-playing, probabilistic reasoning, resource management and strategic decision-making.
Participants assume the role of municipal decision-makers responsible for maintaining disaster risk below an acceptable threshold while managing limited financial resources.
Principal methodological approaches
- Simulation-based learning: Players experience simplified representations of real disaster risk management processes and explore the consequences of different decisions.
- Role-based learning: Participants act as municipal decision-makers responsible for selecting and financing measures to reduce disaster risk.
- Systems thinking: Gameplay represents risk as the interaction of three components: hazard, exposure and vulnerability.
- Probabilistic reasoning: Twelve-sided dice introduce uncertainty and demonstrate that disaster risk cannot be completely eliminated.
- Resource management: Players allocate limited municipal budgets to different risk reduction measures while considering installation and maintenance costs.
- Strategic decision-making: Participants compare alternative interventions and decide how to distribute resources among prevention and preparedness measures.
- Risk reduction mechanisms: Cards represent interventions affecting hazard, exposure or vulnerability, allowing players to explore different approaches to reducing overall risk.
- Uncertainty and incomplete information: The effectiveness of some interventions is initially hidden, requiring decisions without complete knowledge of their eventual outcomes.
- Event-driven learning: Chance cards introduce unexpected developments that can increase or decrease risk.
- Scenario-based learning: Different global scenarios modify the difficulty of managing disaster risk and represent changing environmental, social or economic conditions.
- Progressive decision-making: Successive rounds require participants to reconsider previous investments, maintain protective measures and respond to emerging circumstances.
- Collaborative discussion: The game can be played by teams, encouraging participants to debate intervention priorities and justify their decisions.
- Experiential learning: Players learn through decision-making, simulated consequences and reflection rather than exclusively through theoretical explanations.
- Transferable learning: A common set of gameplay rules is adapted to different hazards, enabling learners to compare risk management strategies across environmental contexts.
Core game mechanics
The principal learning mechanism represents disaster risk through three components:
Risk = Hazard × Exposure × Vulnerability.
During each round, players experience three main phases:
- Risk assessment: Dice rolls establish the baseline conditions associated with hazard, exposure and vulnerability.
- Risk reduction: Players use their available budget to select interventions intended to reduce risk.
- Uncertainty: Chance cards introduce additional events that may modify the risk conditions.
Additional scenarios represent developments such as climate change, ageing infrastructure or reductions in public funding.
The objective is to keep municipal risk below a defined acceptability threshold over successive rounds.
Physical and digital learning environments
The physical games use boards, cards, dice and scorecards, allowing participants to manipulate the main elements of risk management directly.
The project also developed a digital adaptation using the Godot game engine, retaining the central educational principles while introducing online and individual play possibilities.
The physical board games constitute the primary resources considered for Board Game-Based Learning classification. The digital adaptation is a complementary educational format.
Single-hazard and multi-hazard learning
The original games address individual hazards, including landslides, floods, heatwaves and wildfires.
A complementary multi-hazard version extends the approach to interactions between several disasters, incorporating compound events, socioeconomic scenarios and additional financial constraints.
The methodology therefore progresses from understanding individual risk components towards examining more complex systems of environmental and societal vulnerability.
Although gameplay supports collaborative discussion and team-based decision-making, Safe Haven should not automatically be classified as a fully cooperative board game: the published rules also permit individual players or teams to manage their own municipalities.
6. Implementation & Evaluation
The HuT was implemented between October 2022 and September 2026 as a Horizon Europe research and innovation project coordinated by the University of Salerno, Italy.
The project established ten territorial demonstrators across Europe to investigate innovative approaches to reducing disaster risks associated with climate extremes.
Within Work Package 3, Governance and Policy, the project developed Safe Haven as an educational serious game intended to improve understanding of natural hazard risk and decision-making.
Development and implementation
The first game developed within the Safe Haven family focused on landslide risk. Its educational framework was subsequently adapted to floods, heatwaves and wildfires.
The development involved researchers and specialists from the University of Salerno, the German Research Centre for Geosciences (GFZ), the Euro-Mediterranean Center on Climate Change (CMCC) and other project partners.
Implementation characteristics
- Principal audiences: Secondary school students, educators, researchers, disaster risk professionals and other stakeholders.
- Educational formats: Physical tabletop sessions, team-based activities, demonstrations and complementary online experiences.
- Countries: Italy, Germany and Spain are explicitly identified in the project’s published game documentation.
- Participation: The researchers report that the Safe Haven games were played by more than 200 people across these countries.
- Group organisation: The physical game accommodates up to six players or teams, with four teams recommended for better playability.
- Educational scenarios: Landslides, floods, heatwaves and wildfires, with additional multi-hazard scenarios explored during development.
- Facilitation: Activities may be supported by educators, researchers or facilitators who encourage discussion of the decisions and their implications.
- Materials: Physical boards, risk reduction cards, chance cards, scenario sheets, twelve-sided dice and scorecards.
Dissemination and practical testing
Safe Haven – Landslides was presented and tested during public engagement and scientific dissemination activities, including Futuro Remoto events in Naples and Salerno and European Geosciences Union conference activities.
The project also presented its approach to risk education through scientific communications and professional discussions involving geoscientists and disaster risk management specialists.
The gameplay was designed primarily for secondary school students but was also used with adults and specialist audiences.
Educational evaluation
The game’s evaluation was addressed in a scientific communication presented at the EGU General Assembly 2025:
Evaluating the Immediate Impact of a Risk Awareness Activity: Playing the Tabletop Game Safe Haven – Landslides.
The researchers developed pre- and post-experience questionnaires examining participants’ knowledge, attitudes and understanding of landslide hazards and risk management.
The evaluation addressed:
- Risk awareness: Understanding the relationship between natural hazards and their potential consequences.
- Risk perception: Changes in participants’ interpretation of landslide risks.
- Risk reduction: Recognition of measures that can reduce hazard, exposure or vulnerability.
- Decision-making: Understanding the implications of different disaster preparedness strategies.
- Knowledge acquisition: Differences between responses collected before and after playing the game.
Reported findings
The 2025 conference communication reports encouraging preliminary findings, suggesting improvements in participants’ awareness and understanding of landslide risk management.
The project documentation also reports positive feedback from risk experts, indicating that the game can serve as an accessible starting point for discussing complex risk management concepts.
The implementation of the games with more than 200 participants provides additional evidence of practical use across different educational and professional audiences.
Limitations of the evaluation
- Incomplete quantitative reporting: The publicly available conference abstract does not provide detailed sample characteristics, descriptive statistics, effect sizes or statistical test results.
- Participant distribution: The reported total of more than 200 participants covers different activities and countries, without a complete breakdown by game version or audience.
- No clearly documented control group: The available evaluation summary does not establish the comparative effectiveness of the games against conventional instruction.
- Long-term retention: Evidence demonstrating the persistence of learning outcomes over extended periods was not identified.
- Behavioural transfer: The available reports do not establish whether playing Safe Haven improves actual emergency preparedness or real-world disaster response.
- Version-specific evaluation: The strongest documented evaluation concerns Safe Haven – Landslides; equivalent findings should not automatically be attributed to all other versions.
Overall implementation assessment
The HuT provides credible evidence of practical implementation and preliminary educational evaluation of its physical board games.
Its principal strengths are the documented international use of Safe Haven, the publication of game materials and the development of a pre-test/post-test evaluation framework.
However, the currently available evidence supports cautious conclusions concerning educational effectiveness, particularly regarding long-term learning outcomes and comparative impact.
7. Educational Resources
The HuT developed an extensive collection of educational resources supporting climate risk awareness, disaster risk reduction and strategic decision-making.
The principal Board Game-Based Learning resources belong to the Safe Haven family of original educational board games.
The physical games are openly documented and available through Zenodo, accompanied by printable components, game rules and instructions for assembling the materials.
1. Safe Haven – Landslides
Safe Haven – Landslides is the original game developed within The HuT project. It introduces fundamental concepts of landslide risk, including hazard, exposure, vulnerability, risk acceptability and disaster prevention.
Players assume the role of municipal decision-makers and allocate financial resources to reduce landslide risk while responding to uncertainty and changing environmental conditions.
The educational package includes:
- Printable game board.
- Risk reduction and chance cards.
- Game rules and scenarios.
- Scorecards and setup instructions.
- Do-it-yourself assembly instructions.
- Spreadsheet documenting card values.
Download Safe Haven – Landslides (English)
Download Safe Haven – Frane (Italian)
2. Safe Haven – Floods
This adaptation applies the Safe Haven methodology to flood risk management.
Participants explore different flood prevention and preparedness measures, including flood defence systems, infrastructure maintenance and strategies for reducing exposure and vulnerability.
The game follows the same core mechanics as Safe Haven – Landslides, facilitating comparisons between different natural hazards.
The repository contains the printable game components, rules, scenarios, scorecards and assembly instructions.
Download Safe Haven – Floods (English)
3. Safe Haven – Heatwaves
This version addresses heatwave risk and the relationships between climate conditions, population exposure, vulnerability and preventive interventions.
Players manage heatwave risk in a municipality while selecting appropriate interventions within financial constraints.
The game provides an educational environment for discussing the effects of extreme heat and the importance of preparedness and adaptation.
Developed with the participation of Universitat Politècnica de València, the materials are available in English and Spanish.
Download Safe Haven – Heatwaves (English)
Download Refugio Seguro – Olas de Calor (Spanish)
4. Safe Haven – Wildfires
This version focuses on wildfire risk management, exploring the relationships between fire hazards, environmental conditions, exposure, vulnerability and preventive measures.
Players select and finance interventions intended to reduce municipal wildfire risk while confronting uncertain events and evolving circumstances.
The educational materials include printable boards, risk reduction cards, chance cards, scenarios, game rules, scorecards and assembly instructions.
The game is available in English and Italian.
Download Safe Haven – Wildfires (English)
Download Safe Haven – Incendi Boschivi (Italian)
5. Deliverable D3.5 – Manual for Safe Haven Serious Games
This official project deliverable provides the main methodological overview of the Safe Haven game family.
Prepared by researchers from GFZ, the University of Salerno and CMCC, it documents:
- The educational rationale and learning objectives.
- The structure of the four single-hazard games.
- The relationship between hazard, exposure and vulnerability.
- The principal game mechanics and risk reduction strategies.
- The available physical game resources and associated Zenodo records.
- The development of the complementary online game.
- The multi-hazard adaptation and its additional rules.
- The project’s implementation experience and methodological conclusions.
The HuT D3.5 – Manual for Safe Haven Serious Games (PDF)
6. The HuT Factsheet #3 – Using Serious Games to Promote Risk Awareness
This illustrated educational factsheet, published in April 2026, explains how serious games can communicate complex concepts associated with geo-hydrological risk.
It addresses the relationship between learning objectives and game design, including probability, uncertainty, problem-solving and strategic decision-making.
The factsheet includes photographs of the physical game and discusses the importance of simplicity, educational relevance and engagement.
Download Factsheet #3 – Using Serious Games to Promote Risk Awareness (PDF)
7. Safe Haven – Dedicated Educational Website
The developers maintain a dedicated website presenting the different versions of Safe Haven and providing access to their educational resources.
The website includes information about the physical games, the online adaptation, the multi-hazard concept and related scientific publications.
Safe Haven – Official Game Website
8. Safe Haven – Complementary Online Game
The project also developed an online adaptation of Safe Haven using the open-source Godot game engine.
The digital version retains the central learning objectives while introducing individual and multiplayer modes.
Its design allows classroom activities involving larger groups, with a game master coordinating the multiplayer experience.
The online adaptation is complementary to the physical educational games and should be distinguished from the tabletop resources used for BGBL classification.
Safe Haven – Online Game Information
9. The HuT – Educational Material Produced (D2.5)
Deliverable D2.5 documents educational materials developed within the broader project to support disaster risk awareness, communication and capacity building.
These resources complement the Safe Haven games by providing additional information about the project’s educational and engagement activities.
The HuT D2.5 – Educational Material Produced
10. European Commission – CORDIS Project Results
The CORDIS repository provides access to official information, project reporting, scientific publications and research outputs.
The HuT – CORDIS Project Results
Availability of educational materials
The four main physical Safe Haven games have publicly accessible records containing printable components and instructions for assembling and playing them.
These materials provide a high degree of educational replicability compared with projects that publish only descriptions of their games.
The multi-hazard version is documented methodologically, although a complete independently downloadable physical game package for this variant could not be verified.
The online adaptation is also documented, but its current operational availability should be checked independently before classroom use.
The availability of complete physical game packages, multilingual versions and methodological documentation makes Safe Haven a particularly useful collection of open educational resources for Board Game-Based Learning.
8. Ludus Magnus Methodological Insight
The HuT represents a particularly valuable case for the European Board Game-Based Learning Observatory because it demonstrates how a family of physical educational games can translate complex scientific models into accessible decision-making experiences.
Its principal methodological contribution lies in Safe Haven, a modular serious game system that connects environmental hazards, probabilistic reasoning, resource management and strategic planning.
Unlike educational games designed primarily to reinforce factual knowledge, Safe Haven allows players to explore how different decisions influence the evolution of disaster risk within a simulated municipality.
Methodological strengths
- Verified original physical educational games: The project developed four identifiable tabletop games with complete printable components, rules and educational scenarios.
- Strong integration of mechanics and learning objectives: The interaction between hazard, exposure and vulnerability constitutes the central mathematical and conceptual structure of the gameplay.
- Meaningful simulation: Players experience simplified versions of authentic disaster risk management decisions rather than answering disconnected factual questions.
- Probabilistic reasoning: Dice and chance cards represent uncertainty, illustrating why prevention does not guarantee the complete elimination of disaster risk.
- Economic decision-making: Players must allocate limited resources among competing risk reduction priorities, reinforcing the importance of budgets, maintenance and cost-benefit considerations.
- Incomplete information: Hidden information concerning the effectiveness of interventions introduces an additional dimension of uncertainty and strategic planning.
- Systems thinking: Players explore the consequences of modifying different components of risk and recognise that interventions can operate through different mechanisms.
- Modular educational design: The same core mechanics are reused across landslides, floods, heatwaves and wildfires, enabling comparisons without requiring learners to master entirely different rule systems.
- Progressive complexity: The proposed multi-hazard version introduces compound events, socioeconomic scenarios and interactions between different risks.
- Role-based decision-making: Participants act as municipal decision-makers, encouraging reflection on the responsibilities associated with environmental planning and public safety.
- Collaborative reflection: Team-based sessions provide opportunities for discussion, justification of decisions and comparison of different risk management strategies.
- Documented practical implementation: The project reports gameplay experiences involving more than 200 participants across Italy, Germany and Spain.
- Preliminary educational evaluation: A scientific conference communication describes the use of pre- and post-experience questionnaires to investigate changes in risk awareness.
- Open educational resources: The publication of game boards, cards, rules, scenarios and assembly instructions supports independent replication and adaptation.
- Multilingual accessibility: Different game versions are available in English, Italian and Spanish, facilitating their potential use in different European educational contexts.
Methodological limitations
- Limited quantitative reporting: Although a pre-test/post-test evaluation is documented, publicly accessible results do not provide sufficient statistical information to establish the magnitude of learning gains.
- No demonstrated comparative effectiveness: Available evidence does not establish whether Safe Haven produces better learning outcomes than conventional teaching or other game-based interventions.
- Limited long-term evidence: Knowledge retention, behavioural changes and real-world preparedness outcomes have not been convincingly demonstrated through published longitudinal evaluation.
- Uneven evaluation across versions: The strongest available educational evaluation concerns the landslide game; the effectiveness of other versions cannot be assumed to be identical.
- Simplification of scientific processes: The representation of risk through discrete values, dice and cards necessarily reduces the complexity of real environmental and socioeconomic systems.
- Potential cognitive demands: Understanding probabilities, interacting variables and financial trade-offs may require additional explanations for younger or less mathematically experienced participants.
- Facilitation requirements: Although the physical games can be played independently, guided discussion may be necessary to connect game outcomes with scientific principles and real-world risk management.
- Cooperation versus individual objectives: The game supports team-based discussion but does not necessarily involve a collective win condition shared by every participant.
- Incomplete accessibility evidence: The publication of printable materials and language adaptations does not establish accessibility for participants with all types of disabilities.
- Multi-hazard development: The documented multi-hazard approach extends the original methodology, but its independent educational effectiveness and complete public availability remain less clearly established.
Transferability to Board Game-Based Learning
The Safe Haven methodology offers a useful model for educational board games addressing situations characterised by interacting variables, uncertainty and limited resources.
Its approach could inform educational games concerning public health, environmental management, urban planning, climate adaptation, emergency preparedness and organisational risk management.
The modular design is particularly relevant because it demonstrates how a common mathematical and mechanical structure can be adapted to different educational contexts while preserving conceptual consistency.
From a game design perspective, Safe Haven also illustrates the value of embedding learning objectives directly into player decisions.
Probability is experienced through dice rolls, uncertainty through hidden information, economic constraints through budget management and systemic risk through the interaction of hazard, exposure and vulnerability.
This integration makes the educational content an intrinsic component of gameplay rather than an external set of questions attached to an otherwise unrelated game.
Ludus Magnus assessment
The HuT fully satisfies the core eligibility criteria of the European BGBL Observatory because it developed original physical educational board games, documented their mechanics and learning objectives, implemented gameplay activities with real participants and published reusable educational resources.
Its main strengths are the scientific coherence of its game mechanics, the adaptation of a shared educational framework to multiple natural hazards and the unusually complete availability of physical game materials.
The project also provides preliminary evidence of educational impact through an evaluation framework involving questionnaires administered before and after gameplay.
However, stronger experimental and longitudinal evidence would be necessary before making definitive claims about learning effectiveness or real-world preparedness outcomes.
Overall, Safe Haven constitutes a strong example of how contemporary educational board games can make complex environmental risk processes tangible, encourage strategic reasoning and support discussion of the relationship between scientific uncertainty and public decision-making.
